Contemporary composer Ned Rorem is typically likened to an American Schubert (living in Paris) for the fecundity, emotional range, and quality of his songs (though this represents only one facet of a prolific career). An... more »d Rorem's masterful 1998 cycle Evidence of Things Not Seen would seem to justify that reputation, as does this marvelous anthology from the Rorem songbook of the past half-century. The composer is fond of dividing musicians into the "German" and the "French," clearly identifying himself with the latter for the elusive sparkle and subtle play of shadows that characterize his art. What other kind of sensibility could "through-compose" Gertrude Stein's "I Am Rose" in a deftly perfect 27 seconds? Fortunately, American lyric mezzo Susan Graham intuitively understands this expressive aspect, as does pianist-partner Malcolm Martineau. Graham is constantly attentive to the marriage of music and text in the 32 songs here and phrases their little worlds into being with grace and wit. She can shade to a sweet vanishing point or allow her voice to blossom, orchidlike, into a dazzling profusion of colors. Few of these songs, which draw on the poetry of Walt Whitman, Theodore Roethke, Frank O'Hara, and many others, last more than two minutes. But their resonance lingers, whether in the haunting "Opus 101"--with its lean but potent string trio scoring--or the enigmatic "That Shadow, My Likeness" from Whitman. --Thomas May« less
Contemporary composer Ned Rorem is typically likened to an American Schubert (living in Paris) for the fecundity, emotional range, and quality of his songs (though this represents only one facet of a prolific career). And Rorem's masterful 1998 cycle Evidence of Things Not Seen would seem to justify that reputation, as does this marvelous anthology from the Rorem songbook of the past half-century. The composer is fond of dividing musicians into the "German" and the "French," clearly identifying himself with the latter for the elusive sparkle and subtle play of shadows that characterize his art. What other kind of sensibility could "through-compose" Gertrude Stein's "I Am Rose" in a deftly perfect 27 seconds? Fortunately, American lyric mezzo Susan Graham intuitively understands this expressive aspect, as does pianist-partner Malcolm Martineau. Graham is constantly attentive to the marriage of music and text in the 32 songs here and phrases their little worlds into being with grace and wit. She can shade to a sweet vanishing point or allow her voice to blossom, orchidlike, into a dazzling profusion of colors. Few of these songs, which draw on the poetry of Walt Whitman, Theodore Roethke, Frank O'Hara, and many others, last more than two minutes. But their resonance lingers, whether in the haunting "Opus 101"--with its lean but potent string trio scoring--or the enigmatic "That Shadow, My Likeness" from Whitman. --Thomas May
CD Reviews
The real art of song
04/15/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This was better than I expected. Ned Rorem hasn't gotten the recognition he deserves, but he's one of the American treasures. You have to listen to these with an open mind about just what a "song" can mean. Yes, there are beautiful melodies, but what stands out is the fact that each song wonderfully illustrates the turns of the lyrical poems Rorem is using. the music doesn'tseem like an unnecessary addition, it's a perfect complement. Susan Graham has a radiant voice, but she also uses it smartly (much like a similarly gorgeous singer of today, Renee fLeming)and keeps it all sincere, never affected or cutesy. All told, a really interesting set for music lovers who are tired of the same old fare."
Fantastic!
James A Blockinger | 04/17/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"If Susan Graham is boring, then let me die of boredom. Listen to her silky voice and you're powerless. She's not only an incredibly talented singer but makes the words come alive. This is the real art of singing."
Must Have American Songs
ronpearl | Stanford, CA | 12/06/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"One of the most important American song composers, Ned Rorem, is well represented on this disc. Susan Graham gives very good readings of Rorem's most famous works, and Malcolm Martineau's excellent piano playing gives further life to the songs. If you're interested in American song, this disc is a must-add to your collection."
On Discovering Ned Rorem
James A Blockinger | Waukegan, IL USA | 12/06/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I bought "Songs of Ned Rorem" after hearing "Early in the Morning" played on WFMT. I have to admit I was hooked by the skillfully intertwining of the vocal and piano lines. The rest of the CD was no disappointment. "I Dream of Jeanie" is like no other version you may have heard, with the piano accompaniment playing a recurring octave pattern that remains thoughout a key change! Again the harmony and interplay between the vocal and piano score is fantastic! Having sung Randall Thompson's "Frostiana" version of Robert Frost's "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening," I was again taken by Rorem's sensitive accompaniment. Although Rorem's tempo is somewhat quicker than the Thompson setting, it is equally dramatic. "The Serpent" is downright amusing and the piano score, revealing Martin Martineau's technical skills, is downright awesome! I love Susan Graham's singing and MM's playing, enjoying the duo moreso than the selections with the instrumental ensemble. No reservations about the music selection -- this is a CD I will play repeatedly and discover anew each time. I would have liked a bit more description of each song in the liner notes, however, comments are more general than specific. Even if you're not a "mezzo" fan, (and I'm not), this CD is worth adding to your collection!"
Worthy indeed - a gem
pikamate | Stow, OH | 08/27/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I cannot disagree with "A Music Fan"'s panning of this CD. Having first purchased the Hearing CD which he/she references, I reached the conclusion that Rorem's music was too knotty and "20th century" for repeated listenings and enjoyment. This CD with Susan Graham completely reversed my opinion. The songs are indeed chosen to be accessible, but they are much more than that. They are, simply stated, lovely. This is a disc I will play again and again, and has caused me to investigate many other Rorem CDs. I just came on line to buy it as a gift for a friend. Rorem deserves his due, and this disc gives it to him."