Written for Flagstad
Dag Kyndel | Hölö, Sweden | 02/22/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I must correct a few things here:
1)These songs were dedicated by Richard Strauss to Mme Flagstad. That surely means that he had her or at least a heavy soprano voice in mind.
2) I have another new and cleaned up edition, not the Testament one, but on EMI - and I think the sound is very good.
3) Birgit Nilsson sang these songs and have also recorded them - one of the best versions I have heard, she seems deeply involved.
3) For me the best version ever comes from Elisabeth Söderström/Richard Armstrong on EMI, nla - please EMI, a CD reissue!"
AS A MOMENTO ONLY!
L. Mitnick | Chicago, Illinois United States | 10/28/2007
(2 out of 5 stars)
"The sound here is pretty bad, and while everyone knows that Flagstad had a magnificent vocal endowment, the sound on this aircheck does her no favors. Besides, I think that her huge voice was probably unsuited to these songs anyway. The voice is heavy..very heavy, and she also omits, or rather, dodges a high B flat in the first song, possibly because of her growing fear of climatic top notes, and possibly because Strauss allows the soprano the option of taking the top note or omitting it. All subsequent sopranos have chosen to take the note. Flagstad does not, which makes the line seem somewhat deficient. Perhaps a complete performance of these four songs by Flagstad on a studio recording would be highly desirable, but maybe not. The sheer massive sound of her voice would be overkill. Flagstad's great successor, and probable equal - Birgit Nilsson, never sang these songs. She was a smart lady. Her voice would have proven no more suitable than Flagstad's. What is called for in these songs is a lyric or lyric spinto who can "float" a musical line. For me, Elisabeth Schwarzkopf was ideal in this music. But this live performance was the world premiere of the songs, and Flagstad was the most famous soprano in the world at that time. The sound is not at all even satisfactory - tons of surface noise, limited dynamics, etc. The only reason I can find to own this disc is to either be a real "collector" or a
Flagstad fanatic. I am somewhat a combination of both, but I still do not find this to be a satisfactory listening experience."
FLAGSTAD THE MAGNIFICENT
Stanislaw Bragiel | Melbourne, AU | 12/21/2007
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I wonder if the reviewers above have ever considered that Richard Strauss may have in fact wanted this kind of heavier voice rather than the lighter ones commonly used today. Sure the recordings sound wonderful and the Schwarzkopf recording is lovely to listen to BUT I wonder whether how well her voice would have managed over the heavy orchestration.
There is a live Salzburg 1964 recording with Schwarzkopf and Karajan and the voice sounds a bit thin. There are some recordings of Flagstad in Berlin which are much much better and after a number of listening one begins to reject the lighter voices.
Some years ago I heard an American Soprano singing the Last 4 Songs in Melbourne and she couldn't be heard fifteen rows back in the stalls - obviously the orchestration requires a heavier voice and not just being able to sing the "notes". Lisa della Casa, Janowitz and perhaps at a pinch Norman are other versions are worth listening to. Not just the recording quality but the interpretation!!!! Thats what Strauss wanted."
