There was nothing like the Robeson sound, ever. To describe his deep, rich, perfectly equalized instrument is futile. Go instead to "Balm in Gilead," the opening track, and see if you can listen to the last pianissimo phra... more »se without falling to pieces. Robeson was at his best when the music was slow and the words contained spiritual or social messages. Faster, lighter fare like Kern's "I Still Suits Me" or Gershwin's "It Ain't Necessarily So" find the serious-minded singer out of his element, lacking irony and swing. "Old Man River," though, gets a simple, dignified treatment. It's Songs of Free Men, though, that will just keep Robeson's artistry rolling along, especially in Sony's astonishing transfers. --Jed Distler« less
There was nothing like the Robeson sound, ever. To describe his deep, rich, perfectly equalized instrument is futile. Go instead to "Balm in Gilead," the opening track, and see if you can listen to the last pianissimo phrase without falling to pieces. Robeson was at his best when the music was slow and the words contained spiritual or social messages. Faster, lighter fare like Kern's "I Still Suits Me" or Gershwin's "It Ain't Necessarily So" find the serious-minded singer out of his element, lacking irony and swing. "Old Man River," though, gets a simple, dignified treatment. It's Songs of Free Men, though, that will just keep Robeson's artistry rolling along, especially in Sony's astonishing transfers. --Jed Distler
Kevin G. (kkg-ct) from NEW FAIRFIELD, CT Reviewed on 3/27/2023...
A bit of contrary view. First the voice, truly titanic, one of the most distinct voices ever ...and that's the problem. Robeson's voice overwhelms a good deal of the material with an operatic air. 'Traditional" songs that call for a more modest modulation lose credibility with the perfect bass line and perfect articulation worthy of high opera, not down home. Robeson's voice bursts the seams of the setting and does the music a disservice since his styling a distraction from the material. Worth having in any collection since the voice is national cultural highlight , pick and chose your faves.
0 of 1 member(s) found this review helpful.
LuAnn O. from MILTON, PA Reviewed on 6/9/2016...
Clear, masterful performances of a variety of genres from a man with an unforgettable voice. Of course, Ol' Man River is here, but another wonderful rendition is The House I Live In, very fitting to our day as well as when it was written. One of the most enjoyable CDs I've gotten in a while. Both the piano accompaniment and the orchestral are very fitting and the sound quality is very good.
1 of 1 member(s) found this review helpful.
CD Reviews
Robeson at his best
05/11/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"It's hard to believe that most of these recordings pre-date the advent of magnetic tape: the CD transfer is superlative. The songs and performance are beyond reproach. Notable is the imaginative packaging in miniature 'record album' format, complete with the original cover art by Alex Steinweiss, and a replica of the original Columbia record label applied to the CD.
In response to a previous question: Robeson's performance of Danny Boy (Londonderry Air) can be found on the Vanguard LP entitled "Robeson" (VRS-9037)."
Some of the greatest songs of the last century
T. Bekken | Austmarka Norway | 05/04/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"In the 1940s, before rabid McCarthyism and racism had taken its toll on him, Robeson made these wonderful recordings of spirituals, classics and pop tunes. Accompanied by the solo piano of the incomparable Lawrence Brown, or by an orchestra, the songs ring out with pride, dignity, skill and unmatched integrity. The shameful treatment that Robeson was subject to from American authorities certainly seem grotesquely absurd to a modern listener. The wonderful version of "The House I Live In" included on this cd should forever kill off any suspicion that Robeson did not love his country deeply. This album ought to be heard by millions of people, world wide. Robeson's voice is nothing less than a glorious high point in 20th century music, and it's hard to think of any recording capturing it to greater advantage."
The voice, the sound quality and the interpretation
R. Moonilall | 09/24/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Put this on your stereo and if it is good enough the depth and richness of Robeson's voice will make your fillings rattle and your chest rumble. The power of his voice is awesome. This CD is superbly recorded with no audible noise at normal listening levels."
Pleased
James Walsh | St. Ann, Jamaica | 09/05/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Really enjoyable set of songs. I never tire of hearing Robeson sing. These songs are my constant delight while on the road."