Excellent musicianship, great sound quality
Eugene Koh | Torrance, CA United States | 03/30/2006
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I had never heard of Juliane Banse, nor had I ever heard a single song by Debussy. However, I am familiar with Schiff and Mozart, so I figured I could get exposed to something new without taking too much of a risk that the CD would be a total loss.
I was not disappointed. Banse's singing is lyrical, not too heavy, but not overly floofy either. Her voice had just a hint of the tragic to give Mozart's songs a proper emotional balance. The Debussy songs were also beautiful and beautifully sung.
ECM has also done a great job with the engineering. The sound quality is lively and intimate, full and balanced. I tend to like Philips and EMI labels for their sound on classical recordings, with Philips having a fuller sound and EMI a more lively sound. ECM seems to have the best of both worlds.
My only complaint is that the Debussy songs are not all grouped together on the CD. So you get some Debussy to start, then some Mozart, then back to Debussy, and finish with Mozart. Maybe it's to give it a more recital-ish feel, I don't know. Anyway, highly recommended."
These songs need more than pure tone
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 10/05/2009
(3 out of 5 stars)
"The main impression that Juliane Banse makes here is through the purity of her light lyric soprano. With a background in Baroque music, where unfortunately a lack of personality isn't a detriment, she seems bland and unstylish in both Debussy and more surprisingly for a German speaker, in Mozart. Schiff does his best, particularly in the Debussy set, to enter the composer's special sound world, but the singer swans along making lovely sounds without much attention to the meaning or emotion the words are trying to convey.
Contrary to the enthusiastic Amazon reviewer, who hears a range of moods from carefree to serious in 'Veilchen' and 'Abendempfundung,' these two miniature masterpieces by Mozart sound exactly the same to me as sung by Banse. A great Mozart interpreter like Elisabeth Schwarzkopf, in her classic recording with Walter Gieseking (EMI), has nothing to fear. I'd recommend this CD mainly to listeners who want to relax in the beauty of a voice that isn't going anywhere with the words."