"Sheila Jordan is one of the most important jazz singers of the last four decades, but you wouldn't know it from the size of her recorded output: always one of the least "commercial" of singers, this album (her first under her own name) is one of the few Jordan albums on a major label. It sets the pattern for much of her later work--it has a cast of stellar musicians (Barry Galbraith on guitar, Steve Swallow on [acoustic] bass, Denzil Best on drums), & on some tracks she strips the band right down to a duo format, presaging Jordan's later series of duets recorded with Harvie Schwartz. Though there are moments here (like the amazing "Let's Face the Music and Dance") where her work verges on the experimentalism of her work with George Russell or Carla Bley, mostly this is a set of intimate & subtly shaded standards.I remember seeing Jordan in performance; she is an ebullient performer in front of an audience, & the sheer joy she gives off can be sampled here in "Falling in Love with Love" or "Dat Dere". Yet the real show-stopper was an emotional, draining version of "Don't Explain"; she seemed a little self-conscious about it afterwards ("Just goes to show that there's nothing people like more than a good old depressing ballad.")--I get the feeling that that sort of material draws on areas of herself she doesn't want to go into too often. On this disc there are several such moving vehicles for her ballad-readings: I'd single out "When the World Was Young". The voice is fresher than in most of her other discs (it is truly criminal that she was little-recorded until late in her career), but the depth of feeling is already present.This is a classic vocal disc--one of those vocal discs you could recommend to a friend who "doesn't like jazz singing". It's not as self-consciously musicianly as a Betty Carter disc but is no less intelligent & creative."
A classic
Stephen Elman | Brighton, MA USA | 03/20/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The other reviewers have used up all the superlatives, and they're right. This is a classic of vocal jazz (or ought to be considered so). Sheila's voice at this stage of her career was as fresh and delicate as a rose petal. But don't let the comments about few instrumental solos let you think that the supporting musicians are unimportant. This is a very significant album for all of them. It's probably the most beautiful recording of Steve Swallow's acoustic bass sound (before he left that axe behind to become one of the greatest electric bassists)- "Baltimore Oriole" is one of his essential recordings. It has the utterly superb playing of Barry Galbraith, a master of guitar effects and a brilliant accompanist. And it has Denzil Best, one of the legendary and unsung bebop drummers, in a rare high fidelity recording."
Greatest jazz singer ever
Stephen Elman | 04/26/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"if you want to find a clear voice in jazz, please look for Sheila. This album of the 60's will change your mind in jazz singing. Powerful & swinging freely across the music. Genius!"
The thrill of a singer discovering herself
Stephen Elman | 02/18/2003
(4 out of 5 stars)
"An old girlfriend of mine, upon hearing this album, said it sounded like a woman singing to herself in her kitchen. I haven't come up with a better description since. There's an intimacy, an innocence to Sheila's singing here that is enthralling. Sheila went on to record some masterful albums -- 1977's Sheila and 1989's Lost & Found being among the best -- but it is with Portrait of Sheila that we discover a singer discovering herself. Her mirth is contagious in "Falling in Love with Love," her wistful remembrances in "When the World Was Young" enter the listener's heart like a sigh, and her sorrows are laid out in all their blue beauty in "I'm a Fool to Want You," the loveliest version of this song I have ever heard. This is an essential album for any jazz collection."
I picture a cat fight between Sheila and Helen Merrill...
Eric C. Sedensky | Madison, AL, US | 10/26/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Sheila Jordan is no Helen Merrill, but this recording is the embodiment of what a female jazz singer should sound like. I compare her to Merrill only because Helen Merrill with Clifford Brown is probably my single favorite jazz recording of all time, and I have a hard time arguing to myself that Jordan has not topped it. This is simply a wonderful work. Falling in Love with Love is such a convincing track, and I'm a Fool to Want You puts the Sinatra version to shame. Every track has something different to say, and Jordan plays her voice like a finely tuned instrument to make each song come alive. The supporting cast on this CD is suitably low key, yet efficient and spot-on, anchored by one of the true greats of jazz, Steve Swallow on bass. The Rudy Van Gelder recording is typical of his work for Blue Note (which might put off people who think Van Gelder's work is as flat as the lines on his equalizer), meaning it is very high quality and expertly executed. Although Helen is still my favorite fave, Sheila won me over in one listening, and she will you too. No wonder The Penguin Guide to Jazz Recordings: Eighth Edition (Penguin Guide to Jazz Recordings) makes this part of its core collection. This one should not - cannot - be skipped. (Might as well pick up Helen Merrill, too.)"