Thomas Quasthoff and 'Die schöne Müllerin': An Introspective
Grady Harp | Los Angeles, CA United States | 04/03/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"'Die schöne Müllerin' of Franz Schubert is one of his most frequently recorded song cycles and the choices are many among some very fine recordings. Usually sung by the tenor voice (Ian Bostridge comes first to mind), Thomas Quasthoff transposes the songs down for his lushly atmospheric baritone and the results are not only a change in timbre, but also an alternative interpretation of this wondrous cycle that for this listener brings new life to the music.
Quasthoff continues to grow as a soloist. Always an intelligent and sensitive singer, his vocal production now seems more warmly secure in every range and the result is singing of the first order unchallenged by the usual hurdles. Quasthoff together with his collaborator at the piano Justus Zeyen bring an introspective, mature, contemplative mood to the cycle - an approach that suggests the singer sees the cycle as reflective rather than impetuous and full of ardor.
In a catalogue that boasts many choices of recordings of this fervent cycle, Thomas Quasthoff and Justus Zeyen offer a mellow, always beautiful, melancholy reading, one filled with exquisitely beautiful moments and honesty. Highly recommended. Grady Harp, April 06"
Quasthoff's subdued approach is puzzling
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 01/18/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"By almost universal agreement Thomas Quasthoff is pre-eminent in Lieder, and I have eagerly boutht each and every one of his recordings. But this subdued Schone Mullerin puzzles me. quasthoff seems determined, as the Amazon reviewer rightly notes, to turn the song cycle into an "intimate monologue," which evens out the emotional arc and deprives us, in large part, of the miller's exuberance and joy before his doomed love afair carries him toward disaster. Quasthoff's first Schone Mullerin, for rCA, was more direct, less refined.
In keeping with the singer's interpreation, the excellent Justus Zeyen, a wonderful accompanist, tones down the piano part, and that too is a bit of a shame. Fortunately, almost every other Schubert recording by the superb quasthoff exhibits more energy and high spirits."