Bleak But Beautiful
James Donovan | Plainfield, Vermont USA | 12/09/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"A well-made but slightly dour collection, "Winter Songs" is not recommended if you're hosting a party and want some light holiday music in the background. Rather, what we have here is a set of songs where the mood is more reflective. This is demonstrated in the first song, a beautiful, melancholy track that sets the tone for the rest of the album. The album title is misleading, as only about a little more than half of the songs here have anything to do with Christmas or the winter season. The first single, "Stay", a cover of the Sugarland song, deals with a love triangle, and for some reason, the Carpenters song, "I Won't Last A Day Without You," closes out the album.
So why am I giving this five stars? Because it's simply a beautiful and at times, haunting, album. While all the songs are good, the absolute standout track is "Little Drummer Boy." For this song, Keating and producer Stephen Lipson give it an almost ethereal feel, while featuring a stunning guest vocal by the late Stephen Gately. Other noteworthy songs include the Keating original "It's Only Christmas," and the Joni Mitchell classic "River." Overall, this is the type of holiday release best enjoyed when you have some quiet time to listen, with the snow falling softly outside."