HE SANG AS THOUGH HIS LIFE DEPENDED ON IT
Barry McCanna | Normandy, France | 11/07/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Lanza himself said that he sang as though his life depended on it, and that is obvious from the opening bars of every track on this compilation. He modelled himself on his idol Caruso, and his rich powerful voice enabled him to follow in that full-throated tradition. That style of singing was criticised by those weaned on the softer approach of the Gigli school, but modern taste seems to have swung back in his favour, as witness the success of Luciano Pavarotti.
The accompanists include Paul Baron, Henri René, Ray Sinatra, and Constantine Callinicos conducting the RCA Victor Orchestra, and the compilation falls into four main categories. Of the 99 tracks, 12 by my count are operatic arias, including three duets with Elaine Malbin, 27 come from shows or films, including those in which Lanza either appeared or sang, 15 are Christmas carols, and the remainder are popular songs. The carols are grouped together in the latter part of the fourth disc, and to my mind it would have made sense to group the operatic items together also, rather than in separate lots across three CDs.
Those familiar with Lanza's recordings will know also that his intonation was occasionally faulty, and nor did he always temper the dynamics of his voice to the mood of the song (as witness "Love Is The Sweetest Thing"). But those are minor cavils because most of these tracks are a sublime pairing of Lanza's glorious voice with superb accompaniments. Transfers are crisp and clear as one might expect given the pedigree of RCA Victor Red Seal.
"