Disappointing
J Scott Morrison | Middlebury VT, USA | 11/06/2004
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I raved about the singing of Canadian contralto Marie-Nicole Lemieux in a release earlier this year of Baroque music (Scarlatti 'Salve Regina', Vivaldi 'Stabat Mater') with Jeanne Lamon's Tafelmusik. Here we have Ms Lemieux in an entirely different realm, lieder of Brahms. And I'm afraid I have to cast a negative vote. The voice is innately beautiful, incredibly rich and at times thrilling, but a mannerism has crept into Ms Lemieux's singing that I find irritating, particularly if one listens to several songs in sequence. Any time she sings a longish note above a mezzo forte there is a gentle attack following by a, to me, enormous swell which she then backs off of. It's enough to make one seasick. In softer songs (as 'Therese' from Op. 86) this is not nearly so noticeable. But when she gets to rather more expressive songs like the lovely 'Feldeinsamkeit,' the anguished 'Über die Heide,' both from Op. 86, or the dramatic 'Mädchenfluch,' from Op. 69, the mannerism is intrusive. Perhaps this is her way of expressing emotion. But if one listens to, say, Christa Ludwig in this same repertoire one is relieved not to have to endure such a bumpy ride. Further, Lemieux's interpretations seem otherwise rather generic as compared to others'. Her pianist, Michael McMahon, a name new to me, is sensitive but a bit reticent. Violist Nicolò Eugelmi, in the two Op. 91 songs ('Gestillte Sehnsucht' and 'Geistliches Wiegenlied') is a huge plus.
Scott Morrison"