Jazz Giant "Meeting His Audience Halfway"
ananas | Chicago, IL | 09/25/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is the John Coltrane album that I always knew was out there, but could never quite find. Beautiful, understated playing, that still maintains the rigors of his avant-garde style, without overwhelming the listener with a barrage of notes. Coltrane is in top form on these tunes, bringing his spiraling sensiblity down to an observable pace. This is the best of the trilogy of albums he did at this time, in which he spoke of trying to "meet the audience halfway, make something for the people." (The other two were the album he cut with Duke Ellington on piano, and the Johnny Hartman album.)
McCoy Tyner is excellent, and Jimmy Garrison and Elvin Jones keep the momentum strong. The Bonus Disc is an excellent addition, a real treasure for Coltrane fans, letting them see into the process of the construction of these classic tunes with many alternate takes. All in all a must have for Trane fans."
Masterpiece Revisited
Jean-Pierre Fouché | 09/25/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Stunningly beautiful. Coltrane plays his heart out, as does McCoy Tyner. Bonus tracks are fantastic."
John Coltrane at his surprising softest and most beautiful
Jean-Pierre Fouché | Grahamstown, Eastern Cape South Africa | 06/03/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Thank you for publishing this cd. I know Coltrane as the wild "sheets of sound" player. On this cd I particularly enjoy McCoy Tyner, who plays beautiful lyrical lines. This is a lovely soft and beautiful series of performances."