Uneven performances of fine chamber music
Nicholas A. Deutsch | New York, NY USA | 02/01/2002
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Of the available discs devoted to the fine chamber music by the great Swiss composer Frank Martin (1890-1974), this sadly must rank low. Its main appeal will be for Martin "completists," as it contains 2 works not otherwise available: the Etudes for 2 Pianos - the composer's own transcription of his 1955-56 Etudes for String Orchestra - & the brief, catchy Overture & Foxtrot for 2 Pianos (1924). They are performed well by the Duo Beersheva & adequately engineered. The quality of the other performances is variable, & that of the lovely 1921 Ronsard Sonnets (for mezzo-soprano, flute, viola & cello) is frankly unfortunate. There are better performed & better recorded versions of all these pieces in other all-Martin collections: the Sonnets on ASV CD DCA 1010, the Trio on Irish Folk Tunes on Jecklin-Disco JD 646-2, the Ballade for Trombone & Piano on Bis CD-71, & the 2 brief pieces for piano solo on Gallo CD-636."