Lawrence E. LaRocco | Berwyn, Illinois | 03/26/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Sinatra's first album with Don Costa is a spectacular collaboration that resulted in a timeless musical masterpiece. Frank is at the absolute top of his game, and it shines through one gem after another. These are songs that Duke Ellington characterized as "beyond category:" "Night and Day," by Cole Porter, Jerome Kern's, "Yesterdays," Erroll Garner's "Misty," and "It Might as Well be Spring," by Rodgers and Hammerstein. But it's Frank's interpretations of "Come Rain or Come Shine" by Harold Arlen and Johnny Mercer and Hoagy Carmichael's "Stardust" that bestow the album with greatness. Costa's orchestra plays an understated introduction to "Stardust," and then Sinatra sings only the verse to the song and completely leaves out the chorus. It gives Carmichael's classic standard a spare, somber, and elegant feel that is almost beyond description. Equally brilliant is Sinatra's passionate, intense, superbly evocative interpretation of "Come Rain or Come Shine." It is the definitive version of that song and ranks among the best ballads that he ever recorded. Costa's lush orchestrations blend perfectly with Frank's deepening baritone, and the heavy emphasis on strings gives the album an operatic feel. You can't list enough superlatives about this album. It's an early example of his work with Reprise from 1961, and it is one of the ten top Sinatra albums of all time. It is classic. It is essential. It is a must-have purchase, and it is PURE SINATRA GOLD!"
Uniquely Frank
Candace Scott | Lake Arrowhead, CA, USA | 07/29/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"No one has ever phrased a lyric like his man. No one. You feel his pain, his pathos, his happiness, his despair and his loneliness. It is a completely joyous experience to listen to this man sing particularly on this moving collection of ballads.The opening track, "I Hadn't Anyone Till You" is an old standard, sung hundreds of times by other singers. But no one can sing it like Sinatra, it's as if you are listening and understanding the lyrics for the first time.Others had greater range or greater voices. None had the inimitable gift that Frank Sinatra possessed and that was allowing you to understand a lyric and feel it deep down in your soul. There is only one Sinatra and this ablum epitomizes his vocal range and showcases his beautiful genius with a ballad.Listen to "Night and Day" and "It Might as Well be Spring..." they will send goosebumps through you. Yes, he was that good and for anyone who appreciates Sinatra or just great music, this is a must have."
Tonight will not swing
Sarah Bellum | Dublin, OH United States | 08/25/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Whoa, this is one outstanding CD and one of my favorites! This was one of Sinatra's best Reprise releases as he was still at his apex when it was recorded. The arrangements by Don Costa complement The Voice perfectly to create a perfect marriage. Sinatra was no stranger to melancholy tales of unrequited and lost love, such as "Spring Is Here" or "Guess I'll Hang My Tears Out to Dry." Like those recordings, this release also features string accompaniment and a slow pace; in contrast, however, the mood here is hardly morose (for the most part). These are love songs, mostly sung directly to his lover. As such, this makes for the perfect CD to play during a romantic evening. The entire CD is exceptional from start to end, though highlights for me are, "Come Rain or Come Shine," "That's All" and the sensational "Prisoner of Love." The re-mastering has left these songs sounding flawless. As with most releases from this time period, however, the running time is only about thirty minutes. If your CD player supports repeated playing, this CD offers the perfect opportunity to use that feature. Buy it!"
Sinatra's Sinatra
Jim M. | Oakland CA | 11/11/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Frank Sinatra once said when asked that he thought he did best vocal work on the 1961 "Sinatra and Strings" album which teams him for the first time with legendary arranger/conductor Don Costa. It would be hard to disagree with his assessment after listening to this album of ballad masterpieces. By 1961 Frank Sinatra had been singing professionally for more than a quarter century and had mastered the art of singing the popular music ballad. The skills honed over the previous 25 years -- immaculate phrasing, long, luscious notes and sheer vocal power -- are all evident in abundance in what may be the high water mark of his spectacular career. You simply will not hear better ballad singing than this. His renditions of "That's All", "I Hadn't Anyone Till You" and "Come Rain or Come Shine" are the highlights of the album and have not dimmed in brilliance nearly 45 years after they were recorded. This album is the gold standard by which all other ballad LPs/CDs should be judged. It's hard to imagine it will ever be topped."
Superior Sinatra
artanis65 | Washington, DC | 01/20/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The early Reprise years are my favorite Sinatra period. He was still singing great songs, and he hadn't yet made any concessions to the pop market which would swamp adult pop music within a very few years. His interpretive skills were still improving from the Capitol Years,and his voice, while deeper and heavier, was more than sufficient to do whatever he wanted. To use a racing analogy; if Sinatra were in a horserace with other quality jazz/pop singers of the period, he was actually increasing his lead over people like Tony Bennett and Nat "King" Cole, who as good as they were, couldn't compete with Sinatra at his best.
"Sinatra and Strings" is Sinatra at his best. It's an extremely dramatic album, with a choice group of love songs, densely arranged by Don Costa. Some of the songs were a bit quaint even for the early 1960's. "Prisoner of Love," with its melodramatic declamation of loneliness and "Yesterdays" which baroquely rhymes "youth" and "forsooth." More recent tunes like "Misty" and "That's All" are some of the best love songs you'll ever hear. The crown jewel is the bluesy "Come Rain or Come Shine" in which Don Costa adds trumpets into a driving string arrangement and Sinatra just nails it. "We'll be happy together/unhappy together/now won't that be just fine." It's a love song for adults.
They used to say you needed to be old enough to buy booze to buy Sinatra. This is music for grownups. Listen and enjoy.