Gorgeous Performances of Great Music -- and More
Lawrence A. Schenbeck | Atlanta, GA USA | 12/07/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This compilation of 19th-century art songs from Germany -- Lieder to the initiate -- would be a treasure even if all it contained were the marvelous performances of these little gems taken from the DG back-catalog, with great artists like Fischer-Dieskau and Jessye Norman present. But besides that, it is also a CD-ROM (at least MY copy is) containing editable sheet music for these selections, translations and notes on the composers, and interactive features that will be especially useful to students and singers. This new feature, called CD-pluscore, may also appeal to ordinary listeners who'd like to go just a bit deeper in their understanding of this music."
Almost Perfect
Dr. Fartmeister | Vancouver BC | 01/23/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"This is indeed an excellent collection of German Lieder, featuring three astounding interpreters of the repertoire. However, the fourth interpreter, the sometimes-great Jessye Norman leaves a bit to be desired. She does have an excellent sound and good delivery, but some of her trademark barking shows up in a couple of Brahms characteristically mellow pieces (one cannot sing Brahms as if it is Shoenberg). That is really my only complaint. But that is no reason not to buy this CD. Fritz Wunderlich's extremely uptempo interpretation of the crowd-pleasing "Ich grolle nicht" alone is worth half the price of the CD, and the other half is more than compensated for by Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau's incomparable performance of Schubert's "Erlkonig", the disc's namesake. Other highlights from these two singers are Wunderlich's subtle, sublime "An die Musik," and Fischer-Dieskau's playful "Marienwurmchen"Christa Ludwig's beautiful soprano soars in her interpretations of Schubert, particularly "Gretchen am spinnrade" and "Lachen und Weinen." Her delivery is nearly flawless, and even my mother (who hates sopranos for some reason or another) enjoys listening to her singing. I would HIGHLY suggest buying this CD if you are studying voice. If you are, you will undoubtedly be studying several of the pieces featured here, and the immaculate renditions presented on this disc will undoubtedly be of great use to you."
Fabulous Recording, Tremendous Student Resource!
Colorado Bernstein | 02/06/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
""Erlkonig - The Art of the Lied" is a fabulous compilation of perhaps the best recordings ever made of the most famous lied ever written. Dietrich Fischer-Diskau, Fritz Wunderlich, and Jessye Norman offer impeccable interpretations of their selected songs. I must differ, however, with another reviewer on the quality of Jessye Norman's singing represented on this CD: it is splendid! It is the tracks recorded by Christa Ludwig which can be hooty and pitch-approximate, especially "Gretchen am Spinnrade." But, all-in-all, the CD is still 5-star. Apart from purchasing Fischer-Diskau's complete recordings of Schubert's lied (which can cost hundreds of dollars!), this is the best representation of German Lied out there.
But, there's more! This special CD, "CD-pluscore", if played on a PC displays the songs as the artists sing them. This is a tremendous tool for the student of singing. The artist's musical interpretation can be studied. Passages can be repeated to aid more rapid learning. The music is actually seen to help improve musical literacy, even if only rhythmically as the piece scrolls through. Just check it out!
"Erlkonig - The Art of the Lied" stands among the best as a top-flight recording. In addition, it offers its listeners a deeper and possibly more rewarding experience with its "CD-pluscore" feature. I give it my highest recommendation! I have visited the Deutsche Grammaphon website and they list 12 "CD-pluscore" recordings. I would suspect they are all of the same quality as Erlkonig. I have just ordered two of them through Amazon."