"This is a great CD. If you buy only one Billie Holiday CD, let it be this one. It moves; it's funny; it's poignant; it's not too loud, and it's great for any time -- especially late evening. Excellent listening."
Wow
G. Sawaged | Canada | 06/20/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This album contains 16 wonderful songs as only Billie Holiday can sing them. Chosen for this album by the great Shirley Horn, they include songs from 1945 through to 1956. When I first got this album I thought that half of the songs I already had on a different compilation, but no...they may be the same songs but not the same performances, which was a nice suprise. Some of the tracks are live performances, while others are studio. This is truly a great album, and Shirley Horn writes such touching notes on how she saw Billie perform shortly before she died, that just reduced me to tears it was so sad. This is an album that EVERY music fan should own."
In a Word...Phenomenal
G. Sawaged | 03/13/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I wasn't a great Billie Holiday fan until now. From the very first cut (Lover Come Back To Me), this CD is awesome! Since hearing it, I've become interested in all her backup musicians, particularly the ones who seemed to compliment Billie's offbeat, yet wonderful stylizations (such as Lester Young, a soulmate in friendship and musical ability). Hearing the songs made me sad that Fletcher Henderson never thought to blend his band arrangements and Clarence Holiday's strong guitar rhythms to Bilie's halting vocal shadings. If ever a human voice mimicked a horn, hers did and she played with a skill and emotion that touched the soul of the listener. Lady Day was truly one-of-a-kind and this CD captures the essence of of her artistry."
5-star selection, but too short!
cam h. | USA | 08/03/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Billie Holiday is an amazing singer. That's the easy part. The difficult part is sorting through the unceasing number of compilations, reissues, and box sets in her name, the majority of which bear titles with words like best, greats,
essential, or quintessential! I can't tell you definitively (another word that pops up) whether this is indeed the *ultimate* Billie Holiday, but it was a surprisingly good find in my opinion. I have heard several Holiday collections and albums, and this is a nice addition. I think it would be a fair place to begin, as well. The picks are great, but Holiday could make "Baby One More Time" transfixing and deep. The live inclusions are a bonus, and it's nice to see a disc that doesn't favour her "love" songs over masterpieces like "Strange Fruit."Maybe you should look at the title another way: Billie Holiday was the ultimate. Go ahead and get something by her, maybe this one, and begin appreciating her extraordinary talents."