Robert J. from VERO BEACH, FL Reviewed on 10/20/2012...
This is ABSOLUTELY BY NO MEANS your average or even traditional Christmas album. In fact, I can't say that this album has the slightest relationship to any other Christmas album I've heard or collected over the the past sixty years. It's explorative rather than pandering, original rather than humdrum. Marsalis has collected a variety of costars who cooperate, under his direction, in trying to discover the true roots of Christmas music. Not historical roots but emotionally musical roots. You may agree, you may disagree with their conclusions and results, but they can't be disregarded, they HAVE to be taken into account. Do yourself a favor: order and listen to this CD. It will change how you listen to and appreciate Christmas tunes from here on out.
0 of 1 member(s) found this review helpful.
CD Reviews
This is an exquisite holiday CD
08/30/1999
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I picked this one up 5 years ago and have enjoyed it every Christmas since. With the exception of "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" (I don't know what he was thinking on that one), all of the songs are exceptionally well-crafted. This is a perfect CD for trimming the tree. Along with A Motown Christmas, A Charlie Brown Christmas, and Jingle Bell Jazz, this is a holiday essential."
Great jazz...that happens to be a Christmas recording
11/19/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is hands-down the best Christmas recording I've ever heard. A lot of artist feel it necessary to record their favorite Christmas songs and this is no exception. However, Marsalis takes the music to the next step and the result is nothing short of brilliance. With the soothing operatic voice blending perfectly with his trumpet on 'Silent Night' to the bass lines of 'Twas the Night' bringing the song to life - this entire CD is a treat and will immediately put the holiday season in your heart. Cresent City Christmas Card truly is part of Wynton's impressive resume - and not just an isolated Christmas recording. If you're a Marsalis fan - this CD is a must."
Merry Christmas!
JetTone12 | USA | 12/26/2003
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I really enjoy playing this one when it gets to be this time of year. It's a well-played Christmas album. I especially enjoy the version of "Silent Night" with Kathleen Battle, "Carol Of The Bells", "Let It Snow", "Jingle Bells", "Winter Wonderland" and of course "Twas The Night Before Christmas". I thought it was cool how Wynton did the narration along with the music. He sounds good on here. Check this out along with the Tonight Show Band's Christmas album for these purposes."
Second favorite Christmas CD
Todd Post | Arlington, VA USA | 11/19/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I've got to admit, this still takes second place to "A Charlie Brown Christmas" and some of the tracks took me some time to get used to, but it still is my second favorite Christmas CD and five stars on its own merits. There is a great mix of odd jazz interpretation of old classics, classic takes on old favorites, and both instrumental and vocal tracks to mix it up all the more."
NOT FOR cHRISTMAS dINNERNot for Christmas dinner
Thomas Donohue | 12/18/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Don't play this Christmas morning while unwrapping presents of as background to Christmas dinner.
Do listen to it late at night by Christmas tree light with a brandy. This CD rewards listening; the closer the better.
It is our families tradition that this is the first holiday disc played on Thanksgiving day.
What can I say I would love to find more like it...not that CTI commercial dreck"