"Walter Piston is a great American composer and his neglect is a shame. These are two fine mid century American symphonies - tonal and neo-classical in form but definitely modern. The second is a lively war symphony and the first movement includes one of Piston's few "Americanisms" with a jazz tinged second theme. The Sixth is an equally lovely and melodic work, using such instruments as the harp for an unusually lush sound. Originally issued on the Delos label, Naxos is doing us a great service re-releasing these pieces. As one critic noted, a Piston symphony goes out into the world "with buttons buttoned and pants creased." Do not let that fool you - these are well made and handsome works that any music lover can enjoy."
Two of Piston's Finest
J Scott Morrison | Middlebury VT, USA | 08/27/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Naxos continues its welcome reissue of orchestral music of Walter Piston (1894-1976) performed by Gerard Schwarz conducting the Seattle Symphony originally published in the early 1990s on Delos. They have shuffled the contents of the original discs. This one contains Symphony No. 2 and Symphony No. 6, surely two of Piston's most ingratiating scores.The first movement of Symphony No. 2, written during the Second World War and with an unmistakable American flavor, contains two memorable themes, the opening one a long serious string melody followed then by a raffishly jazzy tune with catchy syncopations. The working-out turns the first theme into a delicious canon. The serene Adagio has a Coplandesque simplicity and one of Piston's loveliest melodies, played first by clarinet and then taken up by other winds. The Finale, a kind of rondo, is propelled to an exciting finish by syncopated brass and percussion. This is the Piston made familiar by his most popular score, 'The Incredible Flutist.'The Sixth Symphony was written for the 75th birthday of the Boston Symphony in 1955 and premièred by them under Charles Munch. Movement I is string-dominated, with flashes of harp and piccolo, and is richly harmonized. A long flowing melody features prominently. The second movement is a scherzo with whirling leggerissimo strings punctuated by manic percussion. There is an undercurrent of anxiety. The Adagio that follows, then, is a welcome island of calm. The cello, against impressionistic harmonies, sings an alluring theme, later handed over to the oboe and other winds. The finale, Allegro energico, returns us to bright triadic harmonies and is unmistakably American in its melodic outlines and jazzy syncopations. The work concludes with a restatement of the symphony's opening theme in glorious full-throated peroration.The Seattle Symphony, from their long familiarity with Piston's music, plays these complex scores with the kind of complete control that leads to the illusion of spontaneity. They obviously loved this music, as do those of us who have been made familiar with it through their recordings.Total timing is a bit short at 50:56.Scott Morrison"
DESERT ISLAND DISK! DESERT ISLAND DISK!
rustic | 08/29/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Buy this disk for the adagio movement from sym. #2 alone. Piston did something here that you don't find from a lot of 20th century composers. He wrote a beautiful melody. Piston had a way of being 20th century, but expressive. I think it was Ravel that said, "Music should be emotional first, and intellectual second.""
Superb music in strong performances
G.D. | Norway | 12/10/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I heartily welcome any other installment in Naxos's series of Piston's orchestral music, and truly hope that we will eventually have a complete symphony cycle. Piston might just have been the greatest American symphonist ever (stressing `might') and is at least worthy of being placed among the great composers of the 20th century. Piston has sometimes been compared to Roussel, mostly given the slightly French-inspired take on neo-classicism, but also some of the atmosphere, I'd guess - but Piston's musical language is harmonically more spicy and craggy. One of the distinguishing traits of Piston's music is at least the clarity and cogency of his arguments; it is elegant, vibrant and rhythmically vital, and often tuneful accessible. That goes for both of the works on this disc, at least - they are exactly imaginative, ever-interesting, never outstaying their welcome and brimful of good ideas, skillfully and inventively developed. I have to admit that I haven't heard any alternative performances (there is one of the second by Tilson Thomas on Deutsche Grammophon which I suspect to be a strong competitor, and there exists a Charles Munch recording of the sixth), but the performances here sound excellent to me, full of the sparkle and vitality the music needs, idioimatic and excellently recorded. Strongly recommended"