Is this the next Wotan?
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 10/05/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"In the opera world it's expected that Finland will keep producing one giant, commanding bass after another, in the tradition of Martti Talvela and Matti Salminen. The latest candidate is Juha Uusitalo, by all reports a charmismatic figure on stage. He sings with a charismatic voice, too, full of intensity. It's not a true Slavic bass, more a dark-hued baritone, and I'm not sure the timbre fits noble roles like Wotan -- Uusitalo sounds more like a natural Alberich or Fafner. He suffers convincingly as the Dutchman, though, and the grain in his voice, which has some of Talvela's resin, makes it soulful.
At this point the main lack is individuality. Amfortas sounds just like Wotan, Wolfram, and the Dutchman. Uusitalo becomes more lyrical in the 'Ode to the Evening Star' form Tannhauser but retains the same sobs and nasal twang as elsewhere. The voice's most prominent asset is sheer power and raw emotionality -- those should serve him well on the world's major opera stages. Leif Segerstam, whom I greatly admire in Sibelius, proves a spotty Wanger conductor, but this CD is all about a rising Wotan. On that score, it was intriguing in its future promise.
"