"This seldom reviewed recording has a wonderful cast. Moffo was in full bloom: young, fresh, and vocally secure. Merrill was good, and Solti conducted perfectly. Alfredo Kraus is simply brilliant in the role of the Duke. Absolutely no one in my experience has sung this role better. This remains one of my all-time favorite opera recordings."
Best Rigoletto
Sam W. | Houston, TX United States | 07/15/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I learned that this recording was just removed from the RCA print list. What a shame and what a stupid thing to do. This is the finest Rigoletto ever produced. The dream cast includes Bob Merrill, Anna Moffo (one of her finest recordings), Alfredo Kraus, Roz Elias, Ezio Flagello, and conducted by Solti in a bright, vibrant, and stunning recording. It's also one of the best digital remixes I've ever heard--sharp vocals, quality orchestra throughout, finest mixing. The production is also one of the most dramatic Rigolettos ever, which is as it should be. Rigoletto is after all a descent into evil and revenge, and this recording does it justice throughout. I can listen to this recording over and over. A true modern masterpiece. As an opera singer myself, I find it remarkable."
Electrifying
Michel | Montreal, Quebec | 06/23/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is an electifying set of Rigoletto. Robert Merrill is a
splendid Rigoletto - he conveys the jester's bitterness and
heartbreak superbly through his rich dark voice and incisive
phrasing - his Cortigiani is spine-tingling and the final scene
with his dying daughter is quite hearth-wrenching. Anna Moffo
is a lovely and touching Gilda - she brings considerable warmth
and tenderness to the role and sings an exquisite Caro nome.
Alfredo Kraus is quite simply the best Duke on record charming
and callous all at once - he is in fresh voice and sing with
superb aplomb and exciting high notes. Rosalind Elias and Ezio
Flagello round up the cast admirably. Sir Georg Solti is a bit
hard-driven - the tension remains high throughout but chorus
and orchestra keep up with him. The text is complete and the
sound a bit dryish but quite good on the whole. This was my
first Rigoletto and still my favorite."
Still my favorite Rigoletto
Michel | 02/25/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Rigoletto is a problematic opera... it's so vividly beautiful it almost sings itself so how can you choose amongst all the gazillion recordings out there? I'd never dare say only one was worth buying... but after all these years, I still come back to this one as my definitive version. Anna Moffo's Gilda is amazing... soft and vulnerable, lingering lovingly on high notes... she's touchingly innocent but a deeply felt young woman, not a child. I simply love Robert Merrill's forceful golden richness... his Rigoletto sounds layers deep and his anguish most especially heartfelt. Alfredo Kraus IS the best-ever Duke, no question. His light aristocratic tenor is perfect casting; the seductive youth and irresponsibility and cruelty of the Duke's character are wonderfully present in his voice... The quartet Bella figlia d'amore on this recording with Elias as Magdalena is still unmatchable. Solti must be the real hero of this version because everyone sounds so perfectly and artistically tuned into the music and the story, orchestra and singers alike. The pace is wonderfully compelling and powerful."