A bit frustrating...
Ronald Van Scherpenzeel | Madrid, Spain | 10/31/2007
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Accustomed to give all ACE releases 5 stars because they more than
deserve them, this release is a bit frustrating not only because of
the selection used, but also because some of the greatest tunes of all
times are again in MONO. I know that there are a lot of "purists" who
prefer mono recordings but if an original stereo version does exist,
I prefer that because a lot of "unexisting" instruments on a mono
recording can be heard on the stereo one. There's a lot of difference
when you hear "Save The Last Dance For Me" in stereo. The mono version
loses a lot. Ben E King's "First Taste of Love" is one of the greatest
songs ever if you can hear it in stereo. On this CD it's in mono and
it loses half of the instrumental back-up orchestra. Some other songs
however, like Hushabye, are wonderfully presented so at least it
still can be classified as a 4 star CD.
"
Another great Ace compilation!
John B Goode | Nova Scotia, Canada | 06/27/2007
(4 out of 5 stars)
"At least 12 songs I've never heard before, several that are different versions of songs that I am familiar with.
There are a couple of cases where it would have been nice to hear a mono version instead of the overly familiar stereo (A Teenager In Love for example).
The Del Shannon version of His Latest Flame is a particularly disappointing stereo, and the volume on the track is way too low in relation to other tracks on the compilation. The stereo has nothing happening on one channel for nearly half the record :(.
There seems to be an actual defect on the Fabian track, at about the 1 minute mark.
But these are trivial concerns, compared to having a nice companion to the Leiber and Stoller series.
"