Search - Pyotr Il'yich Tchaikovsky, Raymond Leppard, Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra :: Tchaikovsky: Manfred Symphony/Elegie/Cossack Dance

A relative unknown selection of pieces recorded masterfully

Mark Hughey | Indianapolis, IN USA | 12/18/2004

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Most people's summary knowledge of Tchaikovsky extends to the more 'established' pieces (The Nutcracker, Swan Lake, Symphony #6 (Pathetique), 1812 Overture, et al.) that make their way onto just about every classical compilation CD available. The Manfred Symphony, Elegie, and Cossack Dance ("Gopak") are not as well-known-- or for that matter as melodically memorable, for the most part-- as any of those. So don't expect to be humming the Scherzo on your way to work.



However, that said, whether you're a Tchaikovsky fan or not (I'm assuming the previous reviewer obviously isn't), this particular CD showcases Leppard and the ISO at their well-honed best. The Elegie begins with an almost tender feel, appropriately haunting and beautiful at the outset, then giving way to a chorale of tight stringwork. And while the Finale of 'Manfred' is probably not as memorable as the finale to the 1812 overture, it is very expertly arranged and very lively. Con Fuoco, indeed.



What surprised me most is how well the brass at the outset of the Finale complements the rest of the orchestra so very well (the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra not being a particularly large nor brass-heavy symphony orchestra to begin with); surely this is proof of Leppard's skill at molding the ISO over time from a collection of skilled musicians into a single skilled and precise unit. The sound quality of the Koss recordings brings that out in full force here, as well.



While those looking for the more 'memorable' Tchaikovsky pieces might be disappointed with this CD, I would hazard that most classical music lovers would very likely enjoy it."