Anticlimactic
Pantone292 | Omaha, NE USA | 07/24/2004
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I've always been a huge Belly fan, and well, Tanya is just the cutest. 'Lovesongs' was a great album. So I eagerly ripped open this CD the day I got it, and listened to the whole thing on a long road trip. I haven't listened to it again. Not that it's bad, but rather it's simply bland. Not enough rock, and too much breathy wavering vocals. She's still cute, though."
Tanya can do no wrong
Tigger64 | Syracuse, NY | 07/26/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Is this the best work of Tanya's career? Probably not. BUT WHEN YOU ARE IN THE MOOD FOR THIS CD, NOTHING ELSE WILL DO. Tanya is a tremendous talent, and this is a different chapter in her career. Slow, dreary, bittersweet, dream-pop. Southern gothic. Tanya can do no wrong.
When you're in the mood for this CD, nothing else will do."
Takes a while, but her grooves are affecting...
jon sieruga | Redlands, CA USA | 09/15/2005
(3 out of 5 stars)
"As a Belly fan, I was initially dismayed at the direction Tanya Donelly was taking in her solo career. She seemed to leave all her rock-&-roll impulses behind her, and her marvelously abstract lyrics became too focused, too gender-specific, so that they didn't mean much to me anymore. This album is like that, and the first mention of her nursing newborn had me losing faith, but time has been kind to "Beautysleep". It has a dreamy quality, but there's a menacing undertone to the disc which makes it much more than a valentine to motherhood. Donelly expresses all kinds of doubts and troubles, and some of the songs have a tough, hard shell. An unobtrusive, uncluttered record, it's a little sterile, but the star herself is in fine, clear voice. I do wish they had worked on a more linear feel to the song-continuity (it has an anticlimactic, stop-&-start feel), which may have created more of a full-bodied mood to the overall disc. As with most CDs, all the truly finest songs are up front, but I did enjoy the "hippie dippie" hidden track, and Tanya never lapses into schtick; she's quirky, even at her most 'mature'."