Tempi too fast!
musikwissenschaft | 10/03/2006
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Jaervi can be wonderful with this kind of repertory -- I heard an overwhelming live performance of the Prokofiev Third Symphony with the NY Philharmonic some years ago, with tremendous kinetic power and orchestral brilliance -- but he takes these pieces far too fast for them to breathe. Even Boulez, not known for his Romantic slowness, is less brisk than Jaervi (Boulez' first two movements of Symphony No. 3 are each a minute slower than these performances). Consequently the climaxes, esp. in the 4th Symphony, feel terribly rushed and robbed of power. Munch or Cluytens are preferable. Technically good, but interpretatively not the best. Roussel needs more leisure for his earthy, Flemish strength to be felt, and for the harmonic, contrapuntal and coloristic richness to be properly heard. (There is also a deep elegiac sadness to the 4th Symphony which doesn't come out at these speeds.)"