A superb "Jupiter" and "big" G-Minor
03/23/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I must say that this is a revisionist's "Jupiter". The tempos were more-than-appropriate for these late 18th Century works, and the phrasing in many places (particularly the 2nd movement of "Jupiter") shows an incredible attention to detail. The "ombra" moments in "Jupiter's" 2nd movement are haunting, and the treatment of the multi-thematic counterpoint in the final movement is difficult to surpass. It should also be noted that these great musical feats were achieved in a "live" concert recording, unlike many previous "reference" printings, threaded together with studio trickery. This recording is a must-have!--John H. Pritchard"
Everything Harnoncourt does is thouhgt through.
H. W. A. Leeuwen | Voorschoten, Netherlands | 01/10/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Here again a prime example of how confronting Mozart`s music can be when performed seriously, with Mozart`s unparallelled genius as a given, and using the means that he had when he wrote. To soem the tempi particularly may seem strange, but Harnoncourt chooses them meticulously, based on the performance practice of the time of Mozart. Read `a musical dialoque`."