Stunning playing and sonics carry the day
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 10/15/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Now that the Alpine Sym. has come into its own and one can forget the decades when it was derided as the brontosaurus among Strauss's tone poems, we have a wealth of choice. No work shows off an orchestra's virtuosity as thrillingly -- not even Ein Heldenleben - and so it comes as no surprise that Europe's powerhouse orchestras have dominated the field, particularly Karajan's Berlin account from the early digital era. Now Jansons, with the advantage of spectacularly lifelife sonics, gives the old master a run for his money.
I have only heard the two-channel stereo version, but there's no hesitation in saying that the Royal Concertgebouw's house label must boast some of the best engineers in the world. Every detail in the playing is vibrantly alive. As intrpreations, both the Don Juan and Alpine Sym. are a trifle soft-grained, lacking Karajan's total command, but overall this is Jansons' most energetic recording in a while. I am not a worshipper at the altar by any means, but he rises to his best here.
On musical merits, I'd place this CD below Blomstedt on Decca, Welser-Most on EMI, and Karajan -- all are more viscerally exciting -- and I won't throw away the gorgeous Vienna Phil. account on Telarc under Previn, but Jansons joins that august company once you include the stunning sonics."