Why the Legendary Status is Deserved.
John Austin | Kangaroo Ground, Australia | 10/21/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Older collectors will need no urging to put this CD by the legendary English pianist in their trolleys. Younger collectors might like to know why the legend developed. There were at least three special qualities in Solomon's playing. Firstly, he had the finger control that enabled him to establish "terraces" of sound. Listen to the slow movement of the first sonata on this CD and you will receive the impression that several instrumentalists are at work, ranked in order and never jumping up or down a level. Secondly, he could maintain a slow tempo with total poise and consistency. Listen to the first movement of the "Moonlight" Sonata to appreciate this. The movement expresses a rapt serenity for almost nine minutes! Thirdly, he had sufficient technique to express a joy and a cascading brilliance in the pianistic intricacies of some of Beethoven's fast movements. His playing of the last movement of the "Moonlight" is an example. Feeding the legend too is the fact that Solomon suffered a stroke that prevented him ever playing again soon after some of these recordings were made. Yes, there are sound quality deficiencies that rob this CD of a five star rating, but Paul Baily's 2000 remastering has minimised them to insignificance. 78 minutes of compelling listening."
For music fans
John Austin | 04/06/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"The recording has a dreadfull sound quality...
But te pianist himself is quite brilliant.If u can focus on the "beethoven" style and the playing it-self, then this must be heard, but if you are in want of a digital stereo high quality sound, forget about it.I must say that the way Solomon plays the first movement of the moonlight sonata is fantastic: it is played slowly (like written on the partition) without ever beeing boring. It is certainly my favorite interpretation."