"This is a quick, easy review to write. I found a very cheap copy of this disc--even cheaper than Naxos' normal great price--so I decided to buy it; mostly for "With the Wild Geese" and "In Ireland," since I already have a good recording of the symphony. Well, the pleasant surprise here is, not only are these great recorded performances of the first two pieces, but this recording "blows the doors off" of the "old" Chandos recording of the Irish Symphony by Bryden Thompson and the Ulster Orchestra--which that label has released and re-released in multiple over-priced pairings a few times, and has now deleted--both in terms of performance and sound quality (I'm not sure what the other reviewer could've found lacking in the recording quality). For those of you who have been looking for the Thompson, stop looking and get the Naxos. My copy of the Thompson my very well be sitting in a used CD bin sometime soon. Naxos does it again!"
Great Irish flavored symphony
Michael Ray | Virginia | 04/04/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"This is a pleasant, enjoyable collection of Harty's best work. The highlight is "An Irish Symphony", where various Irish tunes are interwoven into the music. I immediately was swept away into visions of the countryside of Ireland while listening to this disc, and was impressed at the ability of the music to create such a strong visual picture in my mind. Harty based most of these pieces on themes and stories from Irish history. Strong violin pieces throughout, and a definite Irish flavor. A nice listen for days when you want to escape the busy, hectic, work related stress. I was a little disappointed by the recording itself (it's fair), though for the price, Naxos continues to be a leader in the field. Thus, for such a low price, definitely buy this one if you enjoy classical music!"
Exciting
David Saemann | 06/25/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I have Bryden Thomson's recordings of With the Wild Geese and In Ireland, which I prefer. O Duinn's tempos in both works are a bit faster than Thomson's, building up some excitement but also losing some of the lyrical flow of both pieces. Also, the sound engineering on Thomson's album is better, although the Naxos sound certainly is very good. This is my first encounter with the Irish Symphony. It's interesting to note that Amy Beach also wrote a Celtic Symphony around the same time, which was based on native material as well. The Irish Symphony, however, is the better of the two works. It has sparkle, especially in the second movement, and a wonderfully evocative and atmoshperic approach to the material. O Duinn's performance seems to me to be very good. His orchestra plays well, although I would really like to hear Bryden Thomson's version, too. Collectors wishing to experience Harty's music at Naxos's price need not hesitate."
False value - this is no match for Thomson
G.D. | Norway | 02/14/2009
(2 out of 5 stars)
"No unqualified masterpieces here, but these Harty works are still delightfully charming with lots of good tunes in excellent orchestrations - definitely worth hearing, in other words. Some questions can however be raised concerning the performances here. The strings of The National Symphony Orchestra of Ireland sounds at times dangerously thin and the orchestra is in general no match for the Ulster players on Chandos - the balance is somewhat skewed and details are imprecisely played. O'Duinn's approach is questionable as well, going far too fast at times and rushing over many of the beautiful touches of Harty's orchestrations. On the other hand, O'Duinn certainly manages to whip up some excitement with his fast approach, but in the end it is a poor substitute for magic and atmosphere. Sound quality isn't up to the Chandos standard either - reverberant and loud and with a poor balance. It would be wrong to say that this disc is bad, but there really is no competition here - Thomson on Chandos is your man in these works and with the price-reduction on the Chandos reissues Naxos doesn't even have that advantage."