The Single Greatest Version of the 5th
02/28/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"While Bernstein is quite often too Malherian in his approach to Shostakovich (the 14th). We find both orchestra and conductor in top form here. Every movement is polished, stunning in exacting detail (except the faster finale opening). Mravinsky is no match here, nor is Jansons or Ormandy, or Maxim. The 1959 sound is aslo stunning. Also, Berstein's 1959 performance received raves from Shostakovich himself. With the generous filler 9th, this disc is self- reccomending essential in any collection."
The best version of the 5th. Period.
07/27/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"If you ever decide to look for Shostakovich's 5th symphony, then this is the version to look for. This version blows away all the other versions. Add the 9th and you have a best buy."
Nice Change of Pace
06/10/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"While I personally prefer slower tempos in this symphony allowing more subtlety in the music, sometimes it is just fun to hear it much faster and with more boisterousness. Bernstien has shown us a bit of a different side of this music and I like the overall effect. The NY Phil. is playing great as well. The ninth symphony is splendidly done and is well worth the price of admission alone."