Search - Alfred Schnittke, Boris Berman :: Schnittke: Piano Musik

Schnittke: Piano Musik
Alfred Schnittke, Boris Berman
Schnittke: Piano Musik
Genre: Classical
 
  •  Track Listings (21) - Disc #1

That Alfred Schnittke died just months before this CD's release is of course no coincidence: Chandos seeks to represent his output in its most intense, revealing light as a tribute. These piano works aptly delineate severa...  more »

     
?

Larger Image

CD Details

All Artists: Alfred Schnittke, Boris Berman
Title: Schnittke: Piano Musik
Members Wishing: 0
Total Copies: 0
Label: Chandos
Release Date: 11/17/1998
Genre: Classical
Styles: Forms & Genres, Improvisation, Sonatas, Historical Periods, Modern, 20th, & 21st Century, Symphonies
Number of Discs: 1
SwapaCD Credits: 1
UPC: 095115970423

Synopsis

Amazon.com
That Alfred Schnittke died just months before this CD's release is of course no coincidence: Chandos seeks to represent his output in its most intense, revealing light as a tribute. These piano works aptly delineate several threads in Schnittke's demanding repertoire for the solo piano. The 1960s-era works engage serialism interrogatively, with the Prelude and Fugue (1963) steering 12-note rows in different, opposing directions for traction (a technique that makes the Works for Cello and Piano equally fascinating). The Variations on a Chord (1965) takes its cue from Webern's Piano Variations, Op. 27, playing and replaying tones that recur only in the octaves where they originally surfaced. The variations run from subtle, dreamy ambience to hard-hit toccatas, all of them smelling poignantly of Schnittke's genius for merged styles and end-runs around notions like serialism and pianistic canons. The Improvisation and Fugue (1965), written for the Tchaikovsky International Competition of Pianists (but unperformed until 1975) likewise spins 12-note rows that run canon-like through variations, ending in twists of expanded tones and ringing sustain, as if in wreckage. Heading away from sheer thickness of sound, Schnittke scripted Five Aphorisms (1990) with pithy nodes aplenty, heavily interposing silences among tones. Finally, the Second Piano Sonata has harrowing, long-strung notes that seem to ponder mortality and the limitations Schnittke encountered with his failing health. The Third Sonata interjects extremely slowed pianism with long, silent pauses before turbulent motions turn to pounding energy. Slack solemnity is the Allegro section's main weave, and it smacks of the sadness Schnittke's death has left. --Andrew Bartlett
 

CD Reviews

The merit to exist...
villegem | canada | 04/15/2004
(3 out of 5 stars)

"Schnittke's piano music is masterful. But I cannot share the unbridled enthusiasm Mr. Johnson displays with Boris Berman's playing. I shall take four examples to illustrate my point:



1) In Little Piano Pieces, the Cuckoo and Woodpecker is indicated "vivo" on the score. Mr. Berman's playing is heavy and slow.



2) The Sonata No. 2, dedicated to the wife of the composer, is played by Irina Schnittke in a Sony recording, sadly in dire need of being re-issued so the clocks are set and references are re-established. Mrs. Schnittke's playing is bringing the inner light of this music and contrary to Mr. Berman cold intellectualism, makes it so alive and human. For one, she doesn't take liberties with the text.



3) Sonata No.3: here Berman distorts the time markings of the score, slows down in supposed fast parts -second mvt- or accelerates then slows down in the last mvt allegro while the score doesn't ask for. His slow mvts lack pulsation and thus are devoid of dramaturgy. Simply following what Schnittke wrote would improve those performances.



4) Aphorisms: the same critics as for Sonata No.3 can be levelled against his playing of this piece. Thre is little organic in this cold, intellectual rendition that takes liberties with the metrorythmics of the score.



So Boris Berman's CD should be in a library of Schnittke's enthusiast but CANNOT be considered a definitive version of this repertoire. I already pointed out the Sony recording featuring Irina Schnittke; I also wish to point towards Ms. Ponomareva's recent recordings of Sanata No. 3 and Aphorisms in 2008 and Sonata No.1 and the complete 8 Little Piano Pieces -premiere recording- in 2006 as references."