Search - Robert [Composer] Simpson, Vernon Handley, Jonathan Carney :: Robert Simpson: Symphony No. 3; Symphony No. 5

Two masterpieces from a master symphonist

Daniel R. Greenfield | Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States | 12/02/2001

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Surely Robert Simpson ranks among the greatest symphonists of the twentieth century. The Third, Fifth, and Ninth symphonies are probably his greatest achievements, though I would be hard-pressed to say which of these three is the greatest. A good case can be made for the Fifth, however, which is certainly one of the most original works ever composed. If you have never sampled any of Simpson's symphonic works, this is probably the best place to start. Be prepared, however: Simpson's works are highly dissonant in nature, and they demand a lot from the listener. That dissonance is produced primarily as a result of his style of composition, which is governed by the presence of two opposing tonal centers, which often collide against each other. Simpson's music is not atonal, but bi-tonal. Not for Simpson the angst that characterizes the symphonies of Shostakovich and Pettersson. Instead, there is a much more formal detachment, devoid of any traces of emotion. All the same, his music is fraught with a Brucknerian majesty. As one reviewer has said, it is as though one is encountering some sort of strange interstellar phenomenon, utterly beyond the realm of human experience. This is of course their weakenss and their strength. The Third is probably best-known for its extended last section, which starts as an Adagio and gradually accelerates over the space of some 15 minutes to eventually explode in "Beethovenian momentum". The Fifth is best-known for that incredible single-note pulse which plays in the background throughout most of the work, for the most part inaudible, except at the beginning and at the very end of the work where it quietly endures sphinx-like in absolute triumph. It brings to mind that same enigma that confronts the listener in Ives' "Unanswered Question": Whence the cosmos?, and all those unutterable questions that flood the mind when looking up into the night sky. This is a remarkable recording, with exceptionally well-written album notes. Bravo to Hyperion for its most excellent Simpson series! It's my sincere hope that Simpson's time will eventually come. His music deserves to be heard. These two symphonies are undeniably among the most original symphonic works of our time."

Praiseworthy

Karl W. Nehring | Ostrander, OH USA | 08/08/2009

(4 out of 5 stars)

"Elsewhere, I recommend the remarkable Hyperion CD containing Robert Simpson's 9th Symphony along with a spoken exegesis of the work's themes by the composer himself, a splendid concept that the remarkable Simpson carried out to perfection. This disk lets the music speak entirely for itself, with conductor Vernon Handley, the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, and gifted recording engineer Tony Faulkner all carrying out their duties close enough to perfection to suit even the most demanding listener.



Although many American audiophiles have never heard of Robert Simpson, just a few years ago (before his death in 1997), he was often praised as the greatest living composer of symphonies, and this recording will give you an inkling of why that praise was bestowed. Take my word for it--before you buy yet another recording of Beethoven's Third or Fifth, buy this CD first."