Symphony #1 is the winner here.
David DeLucia | East Haddam, Ct. United States | 12/26/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"All of these pieces are worth a listen, but especially the Symphony #1 which has a particularly haunting slow movement with expert writing for winds. The 5th symphony is similar, perhaps too similar to justify recording both. It strikes me as a slightly watered down version of the 1st symphony, with less interesting themes and motives. As for the 7th Symphony, the second movement is a gentle reflective treatment of wordless children's and adult voices that is very effective. Unfortuately, in the outer movements, the same wordless choirs are used in a more harsh and strident way, destroying the effect. Still, worth acquiring for the 1st Symphony, one of Casadesus' most beautiful works."