The War Sonatas: a legendary musical document
Hiram Gomez Pardo | Valencia, Venezuela | 08/11/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I have been a hard fan of Sviatoslav Richer. His enigmatic pianism, his technical endowment, his portentous sound, his absolute empathy each time he played a musician's score can not simulate however his erratic approach, capricious tempi and even a certain superficiality and lightness in determined composers.
His repertoire was immense but when he played Prokoviev, literally you can figure a lion on the keyboard. I have almost one hundred recordings of Richter, and if I was inquired about the composer that transformed absolutely Richter's mood in the keyboard, this was basically Segei Prokoviev.
These war Sonatas are fundamental documents for any serious collector items. Nevertheless I must underline the Eighth Sonata recorded in 1968 is far superior than this performance.
The bitter treatment, the grasping arpeggios, the cynical gaze beneath the bars and this uncertain atmosphere, the sharp phrasing, the sinister, elusive and mysterious elegance is simply a very special trademark of Richter. Nobody does it better.
The Sixth Sonata was a true battle horse for him Remember for instance his inclusion in the celebrated Recital on Carnegie Hall in the early sixties.
If I had to name about other pianist gifted of similar approach there is just one: György Sandor who recorded a superb Seventh in 1967.
Go for these golden treasures before they vanish from the market.
"
Essential Prokofiev.
Howard G Brown | Port St. Lucie, FL USA | 09/28/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"While there may be marginally better performances of the individual sonatas, having all three on one disc performed by Prokofiev's finest interpretor is a boon to any collection. If I didn't already own this disc, I would still meet the asking price for a used copy."