Lugansky and Petkova are both excellent pianists
Classicalfan | Reston, VA USA | 08/21/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The reviewer who condemns Marietta Petkova's performance of the Preludes is far too harsh. I have listened to the CD of Lugansky's performance of the Etudes-Tableaux and to the 2 CD's of Petkova's performance of the Preludes and they are both excellent. In fact, I'm listening to Petkova's performance of the Prelude Opus 32, No. 2, Allegretto in B flat minor, as I write this review, and it's played beautifully, with passion, delicacy, warmth, grace, sensitivity, and all of the other usual positive adjectives one normally associates with excellent musical performances. As for her performance of Opus 32, No. 5, Moderato in G major, it is absolutely enchanting. In fact, as I listen to one beautifully played prelude after another by this Bulgarian pianist, I am at an absolute loss as to how the previous reviewer managed to be so harsh. I would add, in terms of my own background and qualifications to judge the quality of musical performances, that I own over 400 classical music CDs, including CDs with performances by many of the world's most well-known pianists, including Argerich, Ashkenazy, Brendel, Gavrilov, Horowitz, Perahia, Richter, Rubinstein, Serkin, Vasary, and Weissenberg. Based upon having heard recordings of all of these pianists, as well as others, under no circumstances would it ever occur to me to condemn Petkova's performance of these preludes. She plays wonderfully. There are 3 CDs in this box set, not 2, as the previous reviewer erroneously reports. CD #1 has Lugansky's performance of the etudes and CDs # 2 and #3 have the recording of Petkova's performance of the preludes. All 3 CDs have wonderful performances for an incredibly low price. The sound quality of both the Lugansky recording (1992) and the Petkova recording (2002) is crystal clear. Highly recommended."