WONDERFUL MUSIC MAKING!!
Chicago Musician | Chicago, IL USA | 11/13/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I must agree with the reviewer who gave this five stars. The performances are more refined and tonally sophisticated than some alternatives, but they offer richer musical rewards. When I listen with the score I see that they follow all of Brahms's indications, which leads me to disagree strongly with the reviewer who said that "Much skill is evident, most of it directed away from Brahms's original intentions." The intentions are on the page, but can be interpreted many valid ways. This Brahms playing is certainly leaner and less plummy than some, but it displays a range of emotional subtlety that is breathtaking.
The playing is exquisite and technically impeccable. The string tone is always beautiful and well integrated over a very wide range of colors and dynamics. Gautier Capuçon's cello solo in the third quartet is remarkable. Angelich's playing is extremely refined, full of subtle details and displays a huge palette of colors. The piano tone is always beautiful and singing, but occasionally I thought that Mr. Angelich could have provided more harmonic support with his left hand.
The ensemble is wonderful and the phrasing natural. The widest possible range of emotions is displayed. The finale of the G minor quartet is full of gypsy fire and the slow movements are songful and heart-warming.
I can't praise this recording highly enough. If you buy the cds you in for a musical treat!!"
Gorgeous Recording
Brian D., Hodges | Boise, ID | 10/30/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I'm afraid I have to respectfully disagree with the previous reviewer. I'm tempted to think we are listening to two different recordings. I found this recording absolutely beautiful and full of fantastic playing. I have their Brahms Piano Trio recording and love it. This is definitely a worthy successor. All of the musicians are excellent players and in my opinion infuse the music with passion and energy.
For instance, the cello solo in the Andante of the C minor Quartet is absolutely exquisite and worth the price of the disc alone. In addition, their ensemble playing, intonation and sense of phrasing is impeccable. This is music making of the highest caliber.
I think Brahms himself would've been very proud of these performances and I can't recommend this CD highly enough."
Top marks
Scaffa | Sweden | 12/23/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I fully agree with what is being said in the reviews by "Chicago Musician" and "Brian D., Hodges". There is plenty of great technique on display, in superb, well-balanced sound. Much emotion is expressed but no sentimentality."