Still the best
captain cuttle | Vancouver, Canada | 02/18/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I've had this performance since it was issued on LP in the 1960s, and it has always ranked as one of records I'd grab first if I had 30 seconds to clear the house. No, it isn't a modern recording but the sound is more than acceptable and the ear quickly adjusts. As for the performance itself, it convinces from the first note and combines fire with poetry in exactly the right proportions. Hear the opening of the second movement for the former, the dreamy drift into the slow movement recapitulation for the latter. Above all, the intense concentration of all participants comes through and makes the work feel far shorter than its forty-odd minutes. I've heard many, not all, of the famous recordings of the past 40 years of this work. For me, Gilels runs it closest but Solomon continues to stand alone. That singing tone is unique and emerges from the limitations of 1940's technology with colours intact. Incidentally, don't be put off by the relative obscurity of the conductor. He's in charge of the Philharmonia at its peak and does the orchestra full justice. Interplay between Solomon and the various soloists in the andante, particularly cellist Haydn Rogerson, is magical. Coordination between conductor and soloist throughout is exemplary. I'm not a historical recordings freak. For me, a performance has to be absolutely outstanding to compensate for the sonic shortcomings of the 78 era. This one is."
Brahms 2
roger routledge | Wellington, New Zealand | 07/20/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I first heard this work played by Bachaus with Schuricht the VPO. Other recordings at this level are by Richter and Pollini. But the most convincing of all is Solomon's made in 1948. Of course the sound is nothing like more recent recordings but the performance remain unequalled - ranking with Solomon's Beethoven's 3rd with Boult and his Hammeklavier."