No Question About This Man's Talent
Warren Weise | Lakeville, MN United States | 02/24/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I've often felt that Paul Desmond never really got the respect and recognition that he deserved as a jazz saxophonist. Part of the reason may have been his role in the Dave Brubeck quartet and the limitations it may have placed on his personal role in order to further the overall direction of the group. In his setting here, with guitarist Jim Hall, you will hear a Paul Desmond with much greater drive and intensity but the same eloquent and sophisticated harmonic conception that marked all of his work. There has never been a better motivic improvisor in jazz with the chops and the intellect to continue to fit his improvisational ideas into the chordal frame-work of whatever tune he was playing. I think that especially on "I Get a Kick out of You" for example, listeners will hear an intensity and swing that erase any doubt as to his legacy in the history of jazz alto saxophone. It brings to mind his collaborations with Gerry Mulligan and their two very successful recordings. If you don't have any Desmond recordings away from the Brubeck quartet, I urge you to buy this one. I think you'll thoroughly enjoy it. By the way, Jim Hall is no slouch, either. His spare, thoughtful solo creations seem to be a perfect compliment to Desmond's alto. I would give it my highest personal recommendation as a jazz listener and as a jazz saxophonist for over forty years."
Good Sounds
Ray Fong | 10/10/2007
(4 out of 5 stars)
"An easy listening album with some classic standards. The interfacing of Jim Hall's guitar and Desmond's horn is on the mellow side and misses the driving interlacing of a Desmond and Brubeck track. All in all with all consideration for experimentation, a good album of individual performing although it could have been stronger in the point - counterpoint mix."
Contains hard-to-find "Suzie"
Tea Drinker | New York NY | 01/19/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I bought this imported version of the CD because it contains Desmond's original composition "Suzie," which shows him at his lyrical best. I could sing that tune all day!"