Grammy Winner, indeed!
Joseph Graham | Los Angeles, CA | 02/13/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This fine recording actually DID win a GRAMMY award on February 11, 2007 for Best Small Ensemble Performance. I cannot recommend this highly enough. Cappella is doing some of the best early choral music interpretation coming out of the United States, and is championing the work of a little known and unjustly neglected composer of the New World with elegance and stylistic flair. Kudos!"
NOT first recordings!
John | Iowa, USA | 02/12/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I have yet to hear this recording, and shall purchase it today. I'm confident it is both an excellent recording and a fine performance.
I particularly look forward to hearing it, because I have been a great admirer of Padilla's music, and particularly the polychoral works, for more than 35 years.
There is, however, a glaring error in the "Editorial Review" for this recording. By NO means is this a "first recording!" Several previous recordings of some of this repertoire have been released over the years, including a particularly beautiful performance of the "Exsultate Iusti in Domino" released (probably) in the 1960s on vinyl (obviously) by the Roger Wagner Chorale (that was a wonderful album of 16th- and early 17th-century Mexican and Central and South American choral and operatic works).
Moreover, astute choral conductors have known about this repertoire for many years, and there have been perfectly acceptable performance editions of some of Padilla's choral works available for decades.
That said, I'm hopeful this repertoire will become MUCH more widely-known! It is truly spectacular music, every bit the equal of some of the European works on which it is modelled. And it is important to realize that Padilla and many of his Western-hemisphere contemporaries were often second- and even third-generation residents of the Americas.
So--even though I haven't heard it yet--this gets five stars just for being recorded and released!"