"It's easy to understand how people can arbitrarily give this album 5 stars based on the genius of Otis, the man, THE BIG O. But unfortunately, although the man himself is in top form at this juncture, the band isn't up to snuff.The track selection is fine, and the band handles capably enough, but they're not on equal footing, both in regards to performance and recording; the mix is a little unbalanced. Far better is his "Live In Europe" release, and (if you can find it) his "Live At Monterey Pop Festival"."
Otis Redding's Best Live Album
M. Scagnelli | Brandon, Florida | 03/05/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Recorded in 1966, Otis Redding's In Person At The Whisky A Go Go is his best live album, beating out Live in Europe, and is one of the best and most energetic live albums ever made. The album kicks off with the great I Can't Turn You Loose followed by Pain In My Heart, from Redding's first album. This is followed by the soulful plea of Just One More Day and a great version of his earlier hit Mr. Pitiful. The recording of Satisfaction on here is even better then the version on Otis Blue, and easily rivals the Stone's version. This is followed by three great soul songs, I'm Depending On You, Any Ole Way and the great ballad These Arms of Mine. Reddin then goes into a kickin' version of James Brown's Papa's Got A Brand New Bag, which at least as good as the original. The album closes with the classic Respect. This is just a tour de force performance and you can feel the energy coming off of it. This prooves just how great of a voice Otis Redding had and just how soulful he was. This is an essential album in Otis Redding's catalog and in the history of Soul and R&B."
Otis was unquestionably one of the greatest
Tim Withee | Los Angeles, CA | 03/16/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"soul singers ever. On this side, recorded 35 years ago, he and his band are in top form, threatening to "blow the roof off" The Whiskey.Look at the list of tunes: Respect, These Arms of Mine, Satisfaction, Pain in My Heart, Any Ole Way -- I mean this album hits you upside the head and you come back asking for more!My favorite cut, though, is Otis' version of James Brown's "Papa's Got a Brand New Bag." Hey, I like it every bit as much as James's! This thing just cooks, baby! And keeps on cookin! You like soul from the 60s? Don't fool around, buy this CD. You couldn't spend your money any better! Hey, I've had the vinyl issue of this side forever, and it's been through so many parties, that it's scratched, mutilated and damn near worn out! Glad to see this being put on CD.Wasn't no one better than Otis!"
One of the best R&B performances, ever.
Seth Cargiuolo | Boston | 01/19/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is the best live album I've ever heard without any doubt at all. While the backup band on this release is no competition to Booker T & The MGs, Otis' recording & occasional touring band (heard on Live In Europe), the energy they put into this performance is incredible. The drummer and bassist drive every song with raw, whiskey-dripping, gut wrenching power and emotion. Otis' full-throttle singing (and straight-up yelling) complement the raw production - on the fast ones he rocks the house unlike anything you've heard, and on the soulful tunes, he'll make your cold heart melt. And the horns, oh god, the horns...unbelievable. While this may not be the most polished live recording ever, it's raw energy will make you want to stand up and just boogie/fist-fight/screw with complete disregard for anyone around you. By far the most exciting live record I've ever heard; In Person at the Whiskey-A-Go-Go makes the others all look tired, silly, and weak...buy this right now. Do not hesitate. You know you want to shake your butt. This album will help you lose the fear of looking like an idiot..."
My Favorite Otis Redding CD
RogerOutWest | San Mateo, CA USA | 12/09/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"He was at his best live and this is a great recording. Otis in a studio with strings just does not do it for me. In a live venue he just pours out his heart and soul as nobody else can. This is his best CD. If you only buy one this is it. I have owned the vinyl and CD and memorized every note a hundred years ago. I have no other album/CD that I have listened to more over a longer period of time.I went to the Whiskey A Go-Go a few months ago to hear another band. I hardley noticed them. All I could hear was Otis.That being said, there is one high note the trumpet player goes for and misses badly. Many might not notice, but it bugs me. That is the good and bad of live performances. The point is that Otis and the band had nothing left in the tank after that performance and this should be on everybody's all time great performances list."