Jazzy but lacking in ecstasy.
Dr. M. Scott | Manchester, UK | 06/29/1999
(3 out of 5 stars)
"All the correct ingredients - a great interpreter of French music, a great ensemble and one of the masterpieces of this century - but strangely lacking in the right emotions to successfully convey Messiaen's outrageous visions of joy. To give credit, YPT takes the work at a cracking pace, especially the magnificent finale, but he loses the sense of overwhelming pathos, particularly on the final blazing F# major chord which is not held for anywhere near as long as we have come to expect from rival versions(Myung-Whun Chung & Riccardo Chailly). Hence, a good recording (Chandos have sumptuous sound as always) but not the best recording."