Masterpiece
Daniel Martin | Scotland | 08/21/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"not a whole lot to say really, the pure contrast between both CDs included in this deal covers the whole spectrum of sound, whether hard and in your face like 'star**ckers inc.'(found on the first CD) all the way to the melodic and beautiful version of 'something i can never have'(found on the second CD) it has something for everybody. and as a fan for many years this CD set leaves you feeling complete and at peace once you hear it all, it truly is a masterpiece"
Great Compilation
Ashley Berger | Pennsylvania, USA | 02/24/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I have been a fan for over a decade and this album is a must have. Fantastic from start to finish. Very similar to a concert playlist."
A Superb Album In a Sea of Remixes
Brian L. Wilges | central florida | 04/03/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This halo stacks right up against a full length album. As many of the reviews I read suggested, I agree, it is truly the 2nd disc (the studio takes), still. that will capture your attention. "Adrift and at Peace" is reminiscent of "La Mer" from the fragile, a nice extension. "gone, still" another instrumental that stands out. But the final three tracks will capture you. The title track is lyrically charged emotion with minimalist layering that fits perfectly, a real throw back to _The Downward Spiral_ era. "The Persistence of Loss" is a lonely segue into perhaps the most depressing sound-scape ever conceived... "leaving hope". Trent served his publishing title well with a piece that defines melancholy. Again, for me it's a fresh reminder of how incredible the man who composed _The Downward Spiral_ truly is."