A mutual peak
Frank W. Barham | Greenbank, WA USA | 08/27/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"These performances of the three great Wind Serenades vie with those led by Sabine Meyer on EMI for my heart of hearts. Some relentless carper in the back of my mind suggests that the Meyer versions may seem slightly starchy. At any rate both sets deserve the pantheon. I particularly like the horn-playing on the Philomusica set, but then there is excellence everywhere, clarinets, oboes, bassoons, basset horns. The double album includes Wendt's arrangements for winds of excerpts from Figaro and Cosi Fan Tutte. Zestful and delightful. Beautifully played and recorded, and reasonably priced, this album should not be missed. It represents Mozart's music and American wind-playing at a mutual peak.
-Frank W. Barham"
Performed with real personality, and great sound
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 12/29/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This vivacious set of Mozart's three great wind serenades doesn't list a conductor, which makes it all the more remarkable that the performances are so filled with personaity. The nY Phiomusica has been around for 35 years under one name or another, and it includes top-flight New York free lances. Their skill certainly shows, but I keep returning to how flexible and engaging their phrasing is. Grouped winds, even when the players are expert, tend to sound stiff, like a concert band. That's not true here -- as the reviewer below implies these readings make Sabine Meyer's (and many others) sound starchy.
The sound is vivid and close up, taking you onstage into the hert of the ensemble. Since the Allegros are loud and brash, that means that the sonics aren't always mellow, but that's my only reservation. As someone who has loved the Gran Partita for forty years, it's a pleasure to welcome a version so full of good humor and charm. The wind arrangements of bits from Figaro and Cosi make for nice Tafelmusik fillers."