"The Monkees earned their stripes on the 1986 comeback tour (I saw them twice when they swung through Florida) and i was absolutely spellbuond when I heard they had a brand new album coming out the following summer after all of their original albums charted the year before (in addition to a pretty decent showing on the charts for "That was Then, This Is Now"). The results, while not a totally 60s-sounding album, are not so bad for a band that had been apart the better part of twenty years. I was most impressed with "Heart & Soul" and felt they were totally robbed of a worthy hit single when MTV pulled a complete "sour grapes" move in retaliation for the Monkees not being able to make it to an MTV promotion in early 1987 and replaced "Heart & Soul" on their daily video countdown show (where it was getting extremely heavy voting) with "Honestly" by the Christian metal band Stryper. as a result, the single sank after charting somewhere around #80. "Heart & Soul" was easily as good as any single they'd recorded before and was actually similar to "Start Me up" by The Stones in style. there was no reason that song should have suffered the fate it was dealt. The rest of the album was a decent effort to bring their sound into the 80s, and while it wasn't always successful at doing so, it certainly wasn't anywhere near as unlistenable as some would have you believe. Take it for what it was, a chance to get some new material out there while the iron was hot, with a few pleasant surprises ("Midnight", "Gettin' In" and "Every Step of the Way" are definite high points) and the good sense to have Roger Bechirian produce the album. It might have been a different album with the participation of Mike Nesmith; but with him not in the picture save for one show of the '86 tour and not another appearcne from him until sometime in '89...not a bad effort. The live show was one not to be missed about this time either, with over three dozen songs in the set list and almost half of this album, a great mix of old and new...something for everyone. Judge for yourself and keep an open mind! My copy of the LP is autographed by all three of them from back then, so this holds an even greater memory for me!"
Best Reunion Album...Ever!
Mark Ebert | Lancaster OH | 11/06/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"The Monkees had a huge success with "Then & Now...The Best of the Monkees" and this follow-up project from Rhino Records has even more spirit and life.
What if MORE OF THE MONKEES had been made in 1987 instead of 1967--it would have been this album! Radio missed some awesome songs--including: "Heart and Soul", "Every Step of the Way", "Secret Heart", and "Don't Bring Me Down".
However, what makes it a great reunion album is that it is loaded with reunion songs, tunes that say "welcome back" to old Monkees fans, and introduce new listeners to this great group; examples: Davy's "Long Way Home" and "(I'll) Love You Forever" and Peter Tork's "Gettin' In".
If you are a fan of the Monkees, or just getting into them, I would recommend this as a must (moreso than some of their original albums like CHANGES)."
Good Come Back
Monkees (Johnny) | Staten Island NY USA | 04/21/2005
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Very good try from Mickey,Davy & Peter. This CD came out in 1987 after there 1986 reunion tour. Good songs,Plus good vocals. Mickey and Davy did not play on it. Peter did played on one song. So if you are looking to buy this one, you won't go wrong. Enjoy it. I own five of this copy."
Terrific songs from the band
Monkees (Johnny) | 07/04/1998
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The CD contains songs from the 80's with a great mix of beats: rock and ballads. The rock is not too heavy (no heavy metal or rap). It's also great to sing along with. Definitely a must for Monkees fans."
Monkees with a Glossy 80s Pop Sound
musicfan | NY, USA | 03/19/2010
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I can joke about Pool It as much as the next person. It can be cheesy at times, and the ballads can be a bit sappy or drippy. But I like the album. It isn't brilliant, but I find it to be entertaining. It's fun, and isn't that what the Monkees are about?
Being a Monkees fan and an 80s music fan almost guaranteed that I would like this. Here we have the Monkees doing a pop/soft rock album with an 80s gloss to it. The songs are well-written. They are catchy and there is variety so that it doesn't all sound the same.
Highlights are definitely Heart and Soul, Gettin' In, Don't Bring Me Down, Midnight, and Every Step of the Way. Gettin' In was a good surprise from Peter. It has an off-beat, new wave-ish sound to it. It is an unexpected change in sound for the Monkees and I like it. The songs I don't care for much are She's Movin' In With Rico, Since You've Been Gone, and I'll Love You Forever. I like the story behind the latter, that Davy wrote it with the idea in mind of fans always signing fan mail with "I'll love you forever". But the music isn't very memorable. I'd Go the Whole Wide World is catchy. I like it. Secret Heart is another good one. It's a breezy summer-y song. Long Way Home and Counting On You are more Davy ballads but I like them better than ILYF.
I think this album kind of gets unfairly knocked down because of the time period and the circumstances surrounding it. Looking at the music only, it's good. 80s fans should like it unless they hate the Monkees, and vice versa.
Too bad they did not include the songs from the Then & Now album on this re-issue...they were also nice 80s pop that would have fit in perfectly as bonus tracks."