Search - Melt-Banana :: Cactuses Come in the Flocks

Haiku Punk

__sic__ | Paris, France | 07/07/2001

(5 out of 5 stars)

"There are many short songs in this album and they (specially songs in side B.) sound like punk version of Haiku. It's a style of Japanese traditional poem consisting of seventeen syllables. And each song has strong character because they put excellent ideas into each song. For example, if you listen to the song "Pie War", you can easily understand why it is the tittle. This song sounds just like "Pie War"! This feeling is similar to the feeling when you see magic or comedy.. Songs in this album is music but not normal music. Highly recommended to the people who love both art & punk."

Not what I expected

mike12da | Denton, TX | 11/22/1999

(3 out of 5 stars)

"Ok, I ordered this CD because it was a new release, it is infact a rerelease of Melt Banana's earliest tapes from 93 and 94. I was expecting a NEW album instead of poor recording half songs. It definately is Melt Banana, and the music is just as creative as their other stuff, but the songs are very brief, and the recording quality is AWFUL. Only for collectors I'd say, buy Charlie instead."

If you don't love melt banana, you're doing something wrong

wandering primate: | Everywhere, USA | 11/26/2002

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Based on continous analytical exposure to this band, ie. listening to, reading of lyrics, seeing live, and talking to in person, I have reached a logical conclusion. The members of Melt Banana are obviously highly-intelligent aliens from some wonderful far away planet. They must have came to this planet to share their wisdom, and were struck with how [weak] our earth music is. We should embrace their musical lesson. Some people may not be ready for the sheer brilliance of this insanity, but don't worry, one day perhaps you will evolve. This album is the earliest recorded works, and sure, not the best quality. But what one must keep in mind is that these are the seeds that grew into the Melt Banana you (should) know and love. The foundation of aural perfection. I suppose a first-time listener to this band's particular creations may be better off with a more crowd-friendly release, such as Teeny Shiny or Speak Squeak Creak. But for those already blessed with an appreciation for the vision that is MB, get this album, and rejoice in being better than everyone else."