Search - Mcguinn Clark & Hillman :: McGuinn, Clark & Hillman

A Flawed but Rewarding Byrds Reunion

John Eagleson | Wayne, NJ | 05/31/2001

(4 out of 5 stars)

"At long last, the CD release of one of my favorite albums of my youth. The album is flawed in many ways (a dated '70's production sound, harmonies that often lack the old Byrds magic, and some bland lead vocals by Hillman), yet it still remains a favorite of mine because of the songs. The ten songs are straightforward pop songs rich in melody and hooks, even if the lyrics don't offer too many surprises. For a "Byrds reunion" album, it is a bit light on a McGuinn sound -- only a couple of McGuinn lead vocals and a slick '70's guitar sound replacing the traditional Rickenbacker sound. All this said, tracks like Little Mama, Feelin Higher, Backstage Pass, Stopping Traffic, Sad Boy, and Don't You Write Her Off all stand out with strong melodies and structures that culminate in lilting choruses. It is that quality that makes this an essential listen to any follower of 60's folk-rock or even 70's pop. Only Don't You Write Her off got radio play back in 1979, but just about every track has what used to be called a "radio-friendly" catchiness to it. There were more exciting and cutting-edge things happening in the music world in 1979, but McGuinn, Clark, and Hillman should be recognized for the pop gem that it is, even with its flaws."