Much better than I expected!
10/27/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"As a great fan of the Bernstein recordings (both young and old) of the Mahler Symphonies, I was initially a bit skeptical and reluctant to check out this recording. But once I did, I was very much pleasantly surprised. Inbal's rendition of Mahler's most meandering symphony is clean and focused. It is far superior to the Abbado recording and in some parts even surpasses the Bernstein recording. Its only fault may be that it is almost a little too smooth at times. Still, if you are looking for a great rendition of this piece, look no further - this may be one of the best out there!"
Awesome!
04/28/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is certainly one of the top performances of this symphony ever. Inbal is a great interpreter of Mahler without question. He brings out the music's power with both a keen ear for detail and style and a true sense of expressiveness. The Frankfurt Radio Symphony plays marvelously and the numerous solos are done expertly and beautifully. Denon's recorded sound is also excellent. Inbal's recording of Mahler's 5th is also just as if not more insightful, so be sure to check that one out as well."
An excellent 3rd but....
Ytzan | Athens, GR | 04/15/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Inbal's account of the 3rd is probably (along with his 7th) the peak of his Mahler cycle for Denon. The playing from the orchestra is excellent as is the singing from Doris Soffel. I don't give 5 stars because I find that it doesn't reach the perfection of Horenstein's account for Unicorn, although it's one of the best alternatives to it."