"I have been a long-time admirer of the musicals of Kander & Ebb, particularly "Chicago" and "Cabaret". With "KOTSW," they are at the peak of their prowess, creating a score/lyrics of dazzling and heartbreaking brilliance.Vanessa Williams is astounding as Aurora/The Spider Woman -- one is reminded of the great sultry film vamps of the 30s and 40s, which Aurora obviously is. Williams demonstrates great expressivity in her voice, as well as an impressive range.Howard McGillin is a fine Molina, though in the dialogue sections he tends to come across as a bit too fey. His singing voice is quite good, and he absolutely triumphs with "Dressing Them Up", a showstopping high-camp number. I am anxious to acquire the OBC recording of KOTSW, simply to hear how Brent Carver approaches the role.Brian (soon-to-add Stokes) Mitchell is wonderful as Valentin, capturing well the anger and frustration and initial homophobia of the character, and the development of his relationship with Molina is subtle but convincing. Mitchell is given what I think is one of the most rousing numbers written for the musical stage, "The Day After That".There is a level of sophistication to KOTSW that seems to be a first for Kander & Ebb. This is not to say that they have tried and failed before, but "Chicago" and "Cabaret" didn't call for the emotional sweep which imbues KOTSW; rather, they delivered what they promised: hard, glittering scores with incisively biting lyrics. Particularly impressive among the songs are "Over the Wall," "Dressing Them Up," "Dear One," "Where You Are," "Gabriel's Letter/My First Woman," "Gimme Love," "The Day After That," and "Anything For Him."Ultimately, the score and lyrics succeed on the two leads; Mitchell and McGillin flesh out the characters and give their relationship a complexity and believeability. The score builds up to what I think is the climactic number, "Anything For Him," which provides the key turning point in their friendship, while maintaining the complex nature of their relationship. KOTSW has more than earned its place alongside "Chicago" and "Cabaret" as pinnacles in the careers of Kander & Ebb, and at the same time secures its place as a pinnacle in the genre of musical theatre overall."
Vanessa Williams does well in the title role
Lauren (lauverf@aol.com) | New York | 07/18/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Being a huge fan of KOTSW, I was anxious for this new recording. Miss Williams does wonders in the title role- she has the sexual allure and smooth, sultry vocal quality that former star Chita Rivera was somehow missing. Howard McGillan displays stunning vocal comand...but leaves one longing for the heartbreaking musical interpretations of his predecessor in this role, Brent Carver. (I feel it is worth noting that Jeff Hyslop, the only actor to play Molina on Bway who was not recorded, brought both McGillan's vocal power and Carver's tear-jerking vulnerability to the role). Brain Mitchell does very well -however he somehow didnt' seem to "own" this role as much as others I have seen him play. It is worth investing in this recording simply for Williams' dazzling new interpretations of the score and for the material that is missing on the Original Cast Recording CD that can be found here."
Vanessa Williams sounds GREAT!
brian - | New York State | 07/01/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Although Chita Rivera is a good "spider woman" on the london cd, I prefer Vanessa Williams'smooth and young voice because she sounds(and looks) like a movie actress/temptress of the 30's and 40's. The supporting cast does a good job with the haunting Kander/Ebb music. Kiss of the Spider Woman is a tragic story with great music, and nobody sings the title role better than Vanessa Williams. You will not be dissapointed with this cd."
Vanessa Williams Spins a Captivating Web
brian - | 05/19/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Vanessa Williams is absolutly phenomenal as the title role in Kander and Ebb's KISS OF THE SPIDER WOMAN. Her voice is strong, clear, and seductive, and I will never be able to stop listening to her PERFECT rendition of the title song. Howard McGillin has one of Broadway's most distinct voices, and his baritone is very strong, but actually TOO strong for the role of Molina. Brent Carver's performance will be missed for the vulnerability he showed on the original cast recording. Brian Stokes Mitchell, however, is pure dynamite as the revolutionary Valentine. His voice (love the accent) is sensational whether he is singing in rage ("I Draw the Line") or sorrow (the absolutly BEAUTIFUL "Marta"). In the almost non-singing role of the Warden, Herndon Lackey is chilling in the included dialogues, and Mimi Turque does very well with the moving "You Could Never Shame Me." I HIGHLY recommend this CD, for every fan of great Broadway music."
Musical perfection
David Rigano | NY, NY | 12/06/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I was told after I had already become obsessed with the show that it has a habit of becoming habit-forming. It's an extremely addictive show, mostly because of the intricasy with which it weaves its story. It is beautifully written, with musical themes that have dramatic purpose, unlike the themes used by Andrew Lloyd Webber or Boubil/Schoenberg. When a theme recurrs in this show it takes you back to a dramatic moment from earlier in the show, compounding the magnitude of every moment.
And the performances are spectacular. Vanessa Williams blew me away with her seductive, glamourous, sly Spider Woman. Her performance of the title song cannot be beat. Howard McGillin is heartbreaking as Molina, and the voice on Brian Stokes Mitchell melts me every time I hear it. This score seems to have been written with his voice in mind.
This is just about as good as musical theatre gets, and it is perfect."