I Can't Make You Love Me - Kimberley Locke, Reid, Mike [1]
Over the Rainbow - Kimberley Locke, Arlen, Harold
Apologies to Clay and Ruben, but if anybody should have had American Idol 2 on lock it was Kimberley. Kimberley Locke, that is, whose debut cracks the combination to her creamsicle-smooth vocal chops and coughs up a few su... more »rprises. Most important--and most often missing from the recorded dabblings of her AI cohorts--is a sense of restraint. K-Lo, as fans call her, doesn't muck up her songs with check-me-out vocal trickery. She opts instead for straight-up, bells-and-whistles-free singing, and with a voice as honest and earthy as hers it pays. She nails R&B-slanted selections like "It's Alright" and "Without You," the all-the-makings-of-a-classic love song performed with Clay (Aiken, who, she reports in these liner notes, she now counts as a close friend). If there's a misstep, it's the production on rocker "Wrong," which is, entirely, an attempt to copy the funky gimmickry of Kelly Clarkson's post AI chart-topper "Miss Independence." That bummer aside, best about One Love is the promise it displays in the songwriting department: Locke claims co-writer credit on the back-to-basics R&B lament "You've Changed," this CD's strongest, most convincingly cool track. --Tammy La Gorce« less
Apologies to Clay and Ruben, but if anybody should have had American Idol 2 on lock it was Kimberley. Kimberley Locke, that is, whose debut cracks the combination to her creamsicle-smooth vocal chops and coughs up a few surprises. Most important--and most often missing from the recorded dabblings of her AI cohorts--is a sense of restraint. K-Lo, as fans call her, doesn't muck up her songs with check-me-out vocal trickery. She opts instead for straight-up, bells-and-whistles-free singing, and with a voice as honest and earthy as hers it pays. She nails R&B-slanted selections like "It's Alright" and "Without You," the all-the-makings-of-a-classic love song performed with Clay (Aiken, who, she reports in these liner notes, she now counts as a close friend). If there's a misstep, it's the production on rocker "Wrong," which is, entirely, an attempt to copy the funky gimmickry of Kelly Clarkson's post AI chart-topper "Miss Independence." That bummer aside, best about One Love is the promise it displays in the songwriting department: Locke claims co-writer credit on the back-to-basics R&B lament "You've Changed," this CD's strongest, most convincingly cool track. --Tammy La Gorce
Michael T. Rognlien | Chicago, IL USA | 05/05/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"You know, Kimberly Locke was such a huge personality on American Idol II that I was afraid she would alienate large audiences more used to the packaged popstars usually crammed down our collective throats. I was pleasantly surprised when she made it to the final 3 contestants that season and even more pleasantly surprised to see her album on the future releases section of Amazon. Now that the album is out, almost exactly a year after AI2 ended, listening to it shows it was worth the wait. Kimberly breezes through a handful of genres - nothing too heavy or complex, but all of the songs are perfectly suited to her voice and range. Highlights include 8th World Wonder, a perfectly-crafted pop song, Have You Ever Been in Love, a perfectly-crafted, guitar-driven love song, and the quirky but catchy It's Alright, a little pop ditty about acceptance and friendship. The duet with Clay is also good, and it's nice to see their friendship has translated into artistic collaboration as well.It's a unique thing being able to watch someone go from complete obscurity to pop star status, but of all the people I've watched on American Idol, I think Kimberly (and Clay) handled it with more dignity and style than anyone else. Through extreme makeovers and stylists/publicists/agents trying to make her 'into' something, it's gratifying to see she held her ground and produced an album that shows she already knew who she wanted to be and had the guts to do it her way."
Pleasant surprise
Michael T. Rognlien | 05/05/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I am one of those people who didn't watch American Idol 2, and don't enjoy such karoke type shows, but was convinced by my crazy little sister to purchase 'One Love'. I was pleasantly surprised by how great it is. Kimberley's vocals captured me in her jazz-filled bluesy rendition of 'Somewhere Over The Rainbow'. She was able to renew the song, make it her own, and make someone who utterly loathed the song, completely love it. Her heart-felt version of Bonnie Raitt's 'I Can't Make You Love Me' is powerful and heart-moving. Now the rest of the CD is also very good. From beautiful ballads like 'Before', gospel-like 'Now I Can Fly', rock cuts like "Wrong' and 'Have You Ever Been In Love', to fun pop tunes like 'Coulda Been' and 'It's Alright', and country Shania-like hits like 'I Could' (my personal favorite from the whole album). Also, a sweet, romantic duet 'Without You', which delivers powerful vocals yet again. This CD is sure to please any music lover with it's wide range of genres and fantastic vocals. I'm looking forward to more from Kimberley Locke, as I'm sure she'll be around for a long time."
Excellent CD
Michael T. Rognlien | 06/05/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I don't watch American Idol, so I had no idea who Kimberley Locke was when I bought this album. I made the purchase based on a review from People Magazine. I am so glad I decided to give this artist a chance. She has an amazing voice. The first five songs alone sound as though we'll be hearing them on Rick Dees top 40 countdown in the near future. It was certainly money well spent. I highly recommend this artist."
*** Versatility and Range ***
mchips | Indiana | 05/09/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I like Kelly Clarkson, but it took some time for Kelly's songs to grow on me, having to listen to them several times. With both Clay Aiken's and Kimberley Locke's CDs, I liked every single song on both CDs first time through. It shows off Kimberley's voice beautifully, showcasing all of her powerful yet soulful voice. She has grown a great deal since leaving American Idol. She was good on American Idol, but she is even better now. I believe there's a song for everyone on this CD. With my wide range in musical taste, I loved every song. I am, and always have been, a fan of Kimberley's voice (even through the first few weeks when she was in the bottom three on AI - she was my favorite from the beginning receiving most all of my votes throughout the competition). The duet with her and Clay Aiken on the CD deserves an honorable mention. Their two voices blend and harmonize perfectly. I'm very proud, and impressed, with what Kimberley has done here!! I now look forward to both hers and Clay's second CDs, as well as Jennifer Hudson and Fantasia's first CDs."
SOMETHING FOR EVERYONE!!!!!!!!!!
law808489 | mosheim, TN United States | 05/05/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I AM IN AWE OF KIMBERLEY LOCKE, HER BEAUTY AND TALENT ARE AMAZING.this album has something for everyone, pop, r&b and dance. kimberley's voice and this debut album release reminds me of whitney houston when she first burst on the scene. while in the airport, waiting to catch my flight home i read a review of kimberley's album in people magazine, and i was very disappointed to hear only 2 1/2 stars. the writer seems to think that kimberley should have come out with a jazzy r&b cd. why? kimberley should not be put into a box like we do to every other singer. she did the right thing, this album has everything. SUPPORT FOR KIMBERLEY IN TENNESSEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"