Witty parody
William Sommerwerck | Renton, WA USA | 02/01/2010
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I was not quite ready for classical music when "The Baroque Beatles Book" was released. The bits of it I heard made no sense to me, not having the background needed either to appreciate them, or simply laugh.
Rifkin did a first-rate job transposing Lennon/McCartney across two centuries. It's more than merely "professional" -- it verges on inspired. This is not a sloppy spoof, but a carefully constructed pastiche.
Nonesuch had initially wanted Peter Schickele -- who'd already made his mark discovering the long-forgotten works of P D Q Bach -- but he was busy with other projects. Schickele might have done a "better" job, in the sense of creating a greater sense of parody, in both directions. (He certainly would have gone for more-obvious humor.) We will never know.
I should warn audiophiles that the sound is not so hot, even by the standards of 1965. It is overly dry, and seems to have been clumsily multimiked. Some sections are so bad that they sound like mediocre late-40s recordings (but in stereo). And I need not add that, not only did Nonesuch wait 20 years too long to reissue this recording on CD, but their charging full price is unforgiveable. It is yet another example of Nonesuch's failure to properly exploit its outstanding catalog."