Outstanding playing of Beethoven's greatest solo works
Vidar Palsson | 09/18/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Ashkenazy certainly has outdone even himself. The content of this album is timelessly unbelievable. I do believe it may be the greatest recording so far of the three "giant" Beethoven sonatas. Without spoiling the surprise amd wonder for those of you who have not yet experienced the magic, I can only promise that the 'Moonlight', the 'Appassionata' and the 'Waldstein' each hold delicious, hidden secrets as interpreted by the performer, and whisk you away into the mind of their composer each time you listen. A Great Escape, indeed! Give your ears a treat!"
One of the very best Moonlights
Vidar Palsson | Garšabęr, Iceland | 12/31/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Ashkenazys recording of the Moonlight is one of the best on the market. It's my personal favorite recording of that work. Ashkenazys tecnique is brilliant and his musical insight is perfect. The other works are also on a the normal high standard that Ashkenazy is well known by. For this price it's not a question, this is the recording your'e looking for of the Moonlight."
Un-Beethoven like
Beethoven111 | Palo Alto, CA | 02/27/2000
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Ashkenazy's Beethoven playing is rather loud and brash, and it is more suited to the late romantic repertoire. I would more highly recommend the playing of the Beethoven specialists, such as Goode, Schnabel, and Brendel."