Mark B. (mbryant111) from N MANCHESTER, IN Reviewed on 10/1/2024...
There are lots of compilations of greatest hits for John Denver and I own a lot of them. What makes this particular CD worth keeping? Leaving on a Jet Plane. John rerecorded it (and other songs) for this GH album and it is much better than the "poppy" version on Rhymes & Reasons. On the 4-disc Country Roads compilation, the R&R version of Jet Plane is present. I haven't found where these GH versions of his songs show up anywhere else than on this album.
3 of 3 member(s) found this review helpful.
CD Reviews
GIVING CREDIT WHERE IT'S DUE
Michael D. Zungolo | Philadelphia, PA USA | 05/31/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"In the 70's, when Denver was at his creative and commercial peak--because he looked like a dork and made bad movies with George Burns and bad TV shows with the Muppets--it was not hip to like his music. I must admit that as a younger man I succumbed to this reasoning myself. I listened to James Taylor and the Eagles but turned my nose up at Denver, whose one hip credential at the time was writing "Leaving on a Jet Plane" for Peter Paul & Mary. . .But if you listen to some of these songs you will realize, if only in retrospect, that there is some real poetry, and some genuine musical majesty working here--particularly in "Rocky Mountain high" and "Take Me Home Country Roads", two of the best hit records of the decade. "Goodbye Again", "Starwood in Aspen" and "Rhymes and Reasons" are underrated songs that would have gotten a lot more respect if they'd been on a James Taylor or Dan Fogelberg album.Fair is fair. The guy could write a song."
Classic Denver at his melancholy best!
Darrell | 01/18/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"John Denver, without a doubt, has to be my main inspiration for guitar. Unlike any other artist, he created such melancholy and images of nature through his songs, complementing them with his soaring, tenor voice and his excellent guitar playing. When I heard he was killed, I sat in my living room and played and sang every Denver song I knew, trying to give them some of the justice they deserved.Though not all of his best songs are on this compilation, I do believe that this collection captures all parts of Denver. Songs like "Sunshine on My Shoulders" and "Rhymes and Reasons" and "Leaving on a Jet Plane" evoke a melancholy spirit while others like "Eagle and the Hawk" and "Country Roads" makes one long for the beauty of nature that only Denver can capture in song.Denver will be sorely missed."
Fantastic music, bad quality CD
Timothy W. Crews | Chandler, AZ USA | 05/05/2000
(3 out of 5 stars)
"John Denver's music, musicianship, and voice have a special quality that will be difficult to match. The songs on this album are just beautiful.On the other hand, the quality of the sound on this CD is close to the worst I have ever heard. It is tinny, noisy, distorted, harsh, and you can hear pitch variations on several songs that seem to come from problems with the master tape. The mixing is such that often the lyrics are drowned out by the music."
So What if he"s not "cool" ?
mspetrillo | Boxford, MA USA | 10/29/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Many times when we look at John Denver, we think he's not cool. Really, not many people admit listening to him anymore. But listen we must, Because that is what music is. Listening, It shouldn't be about being cool. The joy of music is that it speaks to the soul in a way that nothing else can or does. And John Denver does that. John is not cool anymore. But his music will always speak to the soul. This album does that, it speaks to us as humans. "Annie's song" is simply a song that brings joy to the heart. No, its not anything special, but it speaks to us on a level that makes us all human. That was John's gift, He was simple. He spoke simple words and sang simple songs, about the world we humans live in. There is no glitz or glamour in John's music, but there is humanity. And thats something we are dearly lacking in todays world. Listen to this music, I promise you, you won't regret it."