Feeling and depth........
Amandine - FR | Minnesota | 01/18/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This recording is in my top 4 favorites. The composer pulls you into the smooth waves of an ocean and carries you to shore on the ripples of a quality composition. It's exciting, fresh, yet poised. Johann Schmelzer was a man who was detail oriented and strived for perfection."
Some information and a warning
Hoyt C. Devane | Columbia, Missouri | 12/26/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I wish I'd been given more information before I bought this album, though I did get a chance to hear samples of the MP3s before downloading. What I didn't note was that the piece called Sonata quarta (which by the way is from Schmelzer's Sonatae unarum fidium of 1664--all six of which were nicely recorded by Andrew Manze and Romanesca) is chopped up into several pieces, and done so at unfortunate places. In fact, the sonata really is supposed to run all together and it is particulary jarring when it has breaks in it. Until such time as Amazon makes Sonata quarta all one track (and perhaps only available on the "album" as they do with other classical albums), it should only be purchased as a CD. In other words, forget the MP3s.
All that said, I think the album is glorious, which makes it all the more shameful that Amazon has chopped it up (as MP3s) as they have."